Signup date: Unknown
Last login: Never
Post count: 8969
I'd been told by most of my friends who've had vivas that they unofficially got told they'd passed as soon as they walked in the room - the fact that this didn't happen to me instantly threw me and I couldn't concentrate as all I could think was "I've definitely failed" - perhaps if I hadn't been thinking this, I wouldn't have! So try not to have fixed vision of how things will go in the viva, as you could get disconcerted needlessly.
One thing I wish I'd known is that if you're having a panic, you can ask for a break to go out and get some air.
Even if it's a complete disaster like mine was, if the viva was the problem and not the thesis overall, examiners will make allowances (my nervousness is listed as a probable major factor in the viva report and while this doesn't let me off the rewrite, it shows people don't instantly conclude not performing well in the viva means you didn't write the work or are stupid)
It is theoretically possible not to pass your PhD due to the viva, if it is on the borderline between pass and referal. My work got referred and I am now preparing it for resubmission. Having said that, even though my examiner's reports claim that I was borderline before the viva and only failed because of it, if an examiner is hostile and does not seem to be representing your work fairly, you really have your work cut out for you.
Although you can't choose directly, you will probably have the chance to discuss possible examiners with your supervisor. Once you know who is examining, find out as much as you can, not just about their work, but about them. I've since discovered that my external has a reputation for being difficult, but I went into my viva feeling confident as I thought my research was compatible with hers. Once things have gone wrong, it can be hard to change things as there is no "expert's expert" who can judge that criticisms were not justified.
The purpose of the viva is to prove to the examiners that you did the work, that you understand what your work contributes to your field (and it's novel elements) and, importantly, that you are aware of any limitations or deficiencies in your work (which will always be there to some degree and aren't necessarily a problem but you need to be aware of them!). It is known as a defence (esp. in USA) as it is your opportunity to respond to the examiners queries and to explain why you conducted your research the way you did.
Everybody dreads their viva and we've all heard horror stories but really, if a thesis is that lacking, it should be apparent way before you get to the viva stage. Most people have corrections (minor or major), and some people may be asked to do some additional work (with or without a second viva). Another option is for the examiners to recommend that an Mphil be awarded instead. An outright failure is, thankfully, very very rare.
Hi Janet, I have just been through my viva (successfully, thank goodness!). When you finish writing your thesis (after 3 years or so of full time PhD research), it is submitted to a team of examiners (2 or 3 people, experts in your field). They will be allowed a period of time (2-3 months) to read and critique your work. The next stage is for you to meet up with the examining panel to discuss and 'defend' your work. The viva usually takes 2-4 hours.
Ive heard a lot on this forum about 'defending' your PhD with a 'viva'. Im about to start my PhD and dont know much more than this. Could anyone tell me about what it is exactly, procedure etc, and how likely it is to not get a PhD through 'failing' to defend it?
i think this is BPS wishful thinking - the government has recently clarified that it will not fund 3-year training, so universities (I think 12 are BPS-accredited) cannot offer anything other than the 1 year training at present, requiring PGCE. the best thing to do is what youre doing & go ahead with the PGCE. i did research into this a while ago when i wanted to do Ed Psych - all interested parties (BPS, AEP, DfES, FENTO, TTA etc....) had a different take on it, and i got a number of different answers depending on which organisation i asked!
I applied for a PhD and was actually invited for a 2-day interview - is this normal? I read through this board and some people were offered a place without an interview at all, other had 40 minutes interviews .... I wonder what on earth they will be doing to me in 2 full days?
Hi Reece What do your supervisors say? If they selected the topic, then they must have felt that it could be taken to PhD level? If your transfer examiners feel differently then it was a good thing that this was identified (better now than at your actual viva) and demonstrates the importance of the tranfer procedure i.e. this is picked up early enough for you (and your supervisors) to do something about it. Has anyone explained to you why you are not being given a chance to revise your proposal?
Hi Paul, I am tempted to ask 'how long is a piece of string?'! To attempt to answer your first question (how long to get a post-doc job), this would depend on many factors; how many papers you had produced during your PhD (lots of papers helps your 'employability'), whether you are prepared to move away from your home town or abroad (hence more opportunities for employment), whether your PhD supervisors are willing and able to employ you as a post-doc.
How would a typical academic career in molecular biology look, after finishing the PhD? How difficult is it to get a post-doc position and for how long should you work as such? How long does it take before you can settle down in one place? If someone could give me some idea, I'd be very grateful.
Dear Ann
At first i was working on a thesis on T S Eliot but my supervisors told me that they were not able to support me and advised me to choose a topic which they selected for me. When it was the time to upgrade to PhD status the examiners told me that thesis was not going to get to any viable point for a PhD and rejected my request of a second chance to revise it.
High, can is ask is it possible to get funding for a part-time PhD. I am a medic, whom needs help in paying tution fees and some travel costs. I seen that MRC funds part time PhD's, does any one know how we apply for one ...... I am doing my PhD in molecular mechanisms of neurodegenerative diseases (Huntingtons).
Hi Reece
Have your supervisors explained why they are not allowing you to transfer to PhD? Is it a funding problem? Have you been through the official Mphil/PhD transfer procedure (whatever that may be at your institution)? I think we will be better able to advise you if you can give more information on why the university is not supporting your transfer to PhD. Best wishes.
PostgraduateForum Is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, 77 Sidney St, Sheffield, S1 4RG, UK. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766
An active and supportive community.
Support and advice from your peers.
Your postgraduate questions answered.
Use your experience to help others.
Enter your email address below to get started with your forum account
Enter your username below to login to your account
An email has been sent to your email account along with instructions on how to reset your password. If you do not recieve your email, or have any futher problems accessing your account, then please contact our customer support.
or continue as guest
To ensure all features on our website work properly, your computer, tablet or mobile needs to accept cookies. Our cookies don’t store your personal information, but provide us with anonymous information about use of the website and help us recognise you so we can offer you services more relevant to you. For more information please read our privacy policy
Agree Agree