Overview of GUEST

Recent Posts

a 2:2 and an interview
G

Thanks to everyone who ventured an opinion here. I've now had my interview, and I did indeed get asked about the 2:2. I did take responsibility for it and said I didn't like my 1st degree very much, but that I really enjoyed the research part of my masters. Seemed to work as I got offered the PhD on the spot!

Why won't they respond?
G

Wow, thanks. And congratulations! And you shouldn't thank me, thank Dr Mark Thomas of UCL who gave me the advice. I have. (I was just trying to find this thread to tell someone else to read it (*cough* massaging my ego *cough*))

Good luck! and be smug.

a 2:2 and an interview
G

Hey Anon.

Phone up the academic who interiviewed you. Ask for feed back that way. I found its the best way to speak to people. It won't seem too pushy. (Without wanting to seem too smug, check out this thread about phoning people from this forum)

a 2:2 and an interview
G

Thanks Waiting to Pounce. That's good to know. So what exactly is the right sort of student? I'm afraid I don't come off well at all in interviews - pretty dismal indeed! Is it ok to ask feedback twice as I got some feedback and I would like the person to further explain what he meant but without sounding pushy. I was told I should have given more insight/ideas into my MSc project and potential PhD and I want some clarification as to what I should have said. Is that unreasonable and a stupid thing to ask?

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

I also think Dr. sounds alot better than Mrs. but don't mind Miss. However I think you are really impressing yourself (by increasing your self-worthiness and self-esteem in some cases) and those around you by gaining their respect. It is also a good challenge for yourself and something you must want to do for yourself. That should be the value placed on a PhD but unfortunately that isn't always the case! I do think it is necessary to get anywhere in academia/scientific research these days, however not in the past when there were fewer degrees.

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

I really don't think the government knows what it is doing. The 50% target is to impress voters I think if they can say they have improved access to higher education especially for those who would not unusally consider that route! What is really stupid is paying 16 year olds to stay at school!! That really isn't the purpose of education and what's the point if they are only staying to get the money? Great potential students they would make! It detracts from serious students who actually want to learn and get somewhere!

Strange People
G

I do agree that people should at least make an effort to look around the site before asking questions especially if they are just expecting people to find them PhDs/funding. I also think this is a great site and has settled some of my nagging doubts and queries about the process. Thanks for your help.

Biotechnology in Germany
G

HONESTLY, I came to germany with my boyfriend, he got a job, I started a masters in chemistry, Germany is CRAP, to say the least, the people are cold and arrogant and you cant discuss science with them, its just an uphill struggle to prove you know as much as them....the beurocracy here is SO bad - it takes ages to get anything done, if I were you Id have a look at scandinavia, I am now and I wish someone had given me this advice before... on the other hand the beer in germany is well cheap!!!!

Why won't they respond?
G

Waiting to Pounce, if you're reading this thread; thanks SOOOOOOO much for your advice! Ordinarily, I really wouldn't have had the courage to phone my prospective supervisor through fear of embarrasing myself. However, after having had the interview, I have now been offered the PhD I applied for where I had taken your advice and picked up the phone. :)

Strange People - 2
G

Just to save any confusion, the person who initiated this thread isn't me!

right sort of student for a phd
G

Both peace and discussion can be restored until it is seen that discussion does not turn into argument.

Merits of departments
G

I've had interviews at both institutions, and I seemed to get on with the younger supervisor. I asked as I was concerned about their lack of experience with students. On balance I have decided to take the PhD with the younger guy, if I get the offers!

Merits of departments
G

You need to bear in mind that a 5* department is much more likely to have better equipment and facilities, and provide you with the opportunities to network with other researchers internationally. Just because somebody is younger, it does not mean that their energy and communications skills are better than an older person! Have you been to visit both departments and meet the supervisors?

Merits of departments
G

The younger one. I have an older supervisor and he is a nightmare. They are too set in their ways.

Last on to post on this thread wins
G

post