Is it possible to fail PhD after resubmitting the thesis?

posted
13-May-17, 13:47
Avatar for Frida_VI
posted about 1 week ago
Hi, I have recent passed the viva with major corrections. I'm wondering whether how common it is to fail after resubmitting the thesis. I am so nervous about the whole thing. Can't eat/sleep proper for days.
posted
15-May-17, 09:43
edited about 14 seconds later
Avatar for TreeofLife
posted about 1 week ago
You are highly likely to pass at this stage if you have done what the examiners have requested. Try to forget about it for now and focus on other things, the outcome may take a while.
posted
15-May-17, 13:38
edited about 19 seconds later
Avatar for muspectrum
posted about 1 week ago
Hi Frida,
I just finished my PhD after majors. My supervisor told me throughout that it is impossible to fail unless you don't follow what the examiners want. Saying that, top tips:
-when you get the full report through read it carefully and discuss with your examination team. Now is the time to query and maybe even negotiate a few points.
-take your time- Break it into smaller chunks and if your internal examiner is amicable arrange to meet up and discuss. Mine allowed me to send him a new first draft some six months before my resubmission. That was helpful as I then knew I was on the right lines but annoying because he moved the goalposts ever so slightly.
-be prepared for minors. These should be pretty minimal though.
-feel free to PM me also.

Mus
posted
15-May-17, 14:01
edited about 22 seconds later
Avatar for Frida_VI
posted about 1 week ago
Thank you so much for your encouragements and advice. I am so worried to the point that I am sinking into depression. I shouldn't, but I couldn't help it. Your comments make me feel much better!!
posted
16-May-17, 23:08
Avatar for GrumpyMule
posted about 1 week ago
Frida_VI I am in a very similar position. I was awarded the phd pending minor corrections (technically) however these corrections involved re-write or additions to all chapters, more analysis, literature and new interpretations. I was given 6 months. I submitted the corrected thesis this week. Terrified of them saying that it is still no good or even worse than the original.

It's been tough with colleagues and friends congratulating me post-submission and post viva and not understanding that I still had/have a long way to go.
posted
17-May-17, 06:49
by drkl
Avatar for drkl
posted about 1 week ago
It's unlikely that the examiners will change their mind and fail you after you make the necessary revision. If they are not satisfied with the revision, they will just ask for further amendments and clarification.
posted
17-May-17, 15:51
edited about 11 seconds later
by pd1598
Avatar for pd1598
posted about 1 week ago
Grumpy mule, Im in a very similar situation to you, given minors technically, but which are actually quite significant! In currently half way through my 6 months though. It's good to know somebody with a similar result who has submitted the corrections! My supervisor says examiners will normally just accept corrections without too much fuss.
posted
19-May-17, 13:23
Avatar for Frida_VI
posted about 1 week ago
Thank you for sharing your experience. Hopefully, everything will turn out to be fine for all of us. Never give up. Never surrender!!

Postgraduate
Forum

Copyright ©2011
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

FindA University Ltd, Sellers Wheel, 151 Arundel Street, Sheffield, S1 2NU, United Kingdom. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766