Funding in worse Uni or self funded top Uni?

posted
27-Jun-17, 16:47
edited about 6 seconds later
Avatar for lubottini
posted about 1 month ago
I have offers from Queens Belfast and Kings College for a PhD in Law, but only funding granted for the first one. Should I accept a low ranked uni just because of the scholarship? My supervisor is good in Belfast; but I prefer the reputation of King. Do you think it really matters? What should I weight up to make a decision? thanks:
posted
28-Jun-17, 11:21
Avatar for Tudor_Queen
posted about 1 month ago
Hi,

I think the funding and the fact that you already know your supervisor at Queens are real bonuses.

But is there any way of securing funding or partial funding at Kings?
posted
28-Jun-17, 22:58
Avatar for lubottini
posted about 1 month ago
Well, Kings cant offer me any funding at all (they have like 6 per year in the Law department).
Queens Belfast offered me the tuitions.
Surrey (which is like 40 in the rankings) provides me full package (tuition and Research council stipend)
im afraid it will be so hard to do it out of my pocket.
posted
29-Jun-17, 00:07
Avatar for newlease36
posted about 1 month ago
I am not fully certain what you should do, it depends, in part, on how important school ranking is to you. But I do know that being able to secure funding is an important part of being an academic and one of the criteria you will judged upon when applying for jobs in academia. Apparently, and this may not apply to your field, self-funded phders are sort of looked down and at a disadvantage when applying for jobs. so that's something to consider.

Also doing a Phd is hard enough, without financial stress, I say this as a partially funded Phd student. And i.m.o going into debt is not worth the investment, especially if you factor in lost earnings and even more especially when you consider how precarious the academic job market is.

One thing that could offset going to a lower ranked uni is getting publications in good journals.

Just some food for thought. can't say I know what you should do.... maybe it would good idea to speak with an academic (not one of your potential supervisors) and see what they think... if you know someone whose opinion you trust.
I found career services in my uni, are not all clued in.... so beware of them.
posted
29-Jun-17, 11:49
edited about 11 seconds later
Avatar for TreeofLife
posted about 1 month ago
Go for the one with full funding, every time.

You don't want to waste half your time looking for ways to pay the rent.
posted
29-Jun-17, 12:14
by Ephiny 1 star member
Avatar for Ephiny
posted about 1 month ago
I would go for the funding too, it must be so difficult to manage without it unless you have support from wealthy parents or similar.

I don't think ranking matters hugely at PhD level - not compared to publication record. Queens is a good research university (Russell group) anyway, so it's not going to hurt your reputation, I'm sure! Surrey is perfectly respectable too (and has a lovely campus as I remember).
posted
29-Jun-17, 13:28
Avatar for Tudor_Queen
posted about 1 month ago
Yeh not only all the above but when things go rubbish as at times they do tend to (supervisor problems etc) - it is quite a nice feeling that you aren't having to struggle to pay for such a crummy experience but rather that it is funded. If you are really keen on going to one that is highly ranked in your field, then you could apply to like 5 highly ranked target universities next time round and keep your fingers crossed for getting funding.
posted
01-Jul-17, 07:13
by huubte
Avatar for huubte
posted about 3 weeks ago
Queen's Belfast is a worse university? i thought it is a good one except the location
posted
12-Jul-17, 23:25
edited about 21 seconds later
Avatar for lubottini
posted about 2 weeks ago
Thanks for the comments. I think my choice will be Surrey. I cant wait another year when Brexit is around the corner_ i am an EU student and God know whats coming new from all these messy politics.

Postgraduate
Forum

Copyright ©2011
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

FindA University Ltd, Sellers Wheel, 151 Arundel Street, Sheffield, S1 2NU, United Kingdom. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766