Overview of tt_dan

Recent Posts

During the editing process, do you print the papers or read them via the computer screen?
T

I think the title says it all : )

Whilst checking for typos and other errors (for your conference/journal articles that you've written), do you print the papers or just simply read them on your PC/tablet/etc?

Should I retract my paper and send to somewhere else?
T

Quote From MeaninginLife:
But your original idea could be leaked...


Ouch, yes. That's a good point.

Conference folded, paper needs to find a new place; unmotivated : (
T

.Just to update on this, the conference didn't fold fortunately : )

Should I retract my paper and send to somewhere else?
T

Actually, I already did ask the supervisor regarding the conference a long time ago; they never replied to my queries regarding the matter. .

I usually ask people around in the department of course; but I would also ask somewhere else just to get an expended view. So the "effort" is really not the issue; it's just that I'm not getting the answer I'm seeking.

There's nothing wrong with retracting a paper from a conferences (as long as you haven't registered it i.e. payed the fees); you only to need to inform the chair in order to do so.
I posted the post to ask whether or not I should retract and send somewhere else, and see if someone else has the experienced doing it.

Should I retract my paper and send to somewhere else?
T

A paper of mine was accepted to a low-tier conference recently, and not indexed by sources such as IEEE, Scopus, etc. I submitted the paper because I wasn't really confident with the paper; but now I am, and I believe that the paper may benefit from conferences that are indexed by good sources such as IEEE, Scopus, ISI, etc

Should I withdraw the paper and send it to somewhere else?

Any advice is welcome!.

Supervisor and supervise relationship: who's the leader/boss?
T

I've heard a lot about supervisors dominating their PhD students, to the point of making the candidates quit their PhDs or bullying them to the point of making them feel really demotivated.

Assuming that the PhD candidate paid the tuition fees in full, as well as other expenses, wouldn't the student now be the leader/boss or simply the customer (considering they are actually paying the supervisor's salary) and the supervisor is just merely giving a service based on their advises and other obligated tasks?
The supervisor now has no whatsoever right to "order" them around isn't it?

Authorship confusions : [
T

Quote From MeaninginLife:
According to several research guidelines, gift authorship is still unethical.
There were also incidents when some so-called authors revealed that they were unaware of the publications or never read the paper.


My supervisor normally says that he'll read it "briefly".

Authorship confusions : [
T

Thanks Ian and Meaninginlife. Feel a bit better about the whole thing.

I guess I'm still getting use to the academic culture : [

Authorship confusions : [
T

Quote From eading:
"...unpleasantness if you disagree with your supervisor" is the foremost issue ;)


The ",,, unpleasantness" is the issue.

He didn't do any work! - imagine I'm screaming whilst saying this ; p

What to do, what to do : /

Authorship confusions : [
T

Ok, I wrote this paper by myself, 100%, for a few months and it has now finished. I included my supervisor's name since he did give some input on the matter, such as arrangement of abstract and the sort. I also included him because he's the "supervisor".

But a few days ago, he asked me to put in this other author's name that didn't do anything for the paper. The only thing he did was to secure the funding for the paper. Since that is his job anyway, I think his name should be on the acknowledgement, not as an author; am I right?

I'm slightly confused with this decision to put him as an "author". Why? He didn't do anything...
I wanted to ask the supervisor, but I think I'd ask your opinions first regarding the matter. Should I even ask him?

Any advice would be appreciated.

A few questions on published materials
T

Quote From HazyJane:
Quote From tt_dan:
Thanks for the replies.

In your own opinion, what does a bad paper mean?

Do you mean:
1. How do you decide a paper is 'bad'?
or
2. What are the implications of having 'bad' papers that have passed peer review?


I meant the first one; but how about we just go for both : )

A few questions on published materials
T

Thanks for the replies.

In your own opinion, what does a bad paper mean?

@Meaninginlife:
If you want to get published, then heed this advice:
Cite your friends at least once and your enemies twice,
Cite the editor three times, yourself at least four,
And write in a style that's intended to bore.
If you want to get published, here's what you must do
Above all: don't come up with anything new. J.E.C.

Why do you think this advice is good?

A few questions on published materials
T

I'm wondering:
(1)Is it possible to get published in a peer-reviewed place even when the result(s) of the experiment is wrong?
e.g. the peer reviewer somehow missed the erroneous result(s).
(2)Is there actually a "bad" published paper? I've heard a lot of of these "there are so many rubbish published papers", but I don't know what it actually means.

Don't you just hate the waiting? Rant about paper submissions : /
T

Quote From BilboBaggins:
Are you submitting to conferences? If so get used to the idea of much longer deadlines if you submit to academic journals! It can take them a year or more in some cases to reach a decision. And then several more years for the piece to be published.

The best advice is to get on with other things and forget about something you can't do anything about, and will do no good worrying about.

There's always something else you can be working on :)


I'm sending some to conferences; even the waiting is making me anxious #'.'#

Don't you just hate the waiting? Rant about paper submissions : /
T

Title says it all; ergh : /

Maybe "hate" is a bit strong, but it annoys me really when the places where I submit my papers keep on extending their deadlines and notification of acceptance. It makes me anxious! : (

Is there a way not to so feel anxious? How do you handle the wait and the extended deadlines?

Try to get a life/hobby? lol I do have one : p But you know, after the "life" or hobby, I still somehow think about it *'.'*