Close Home Forum Sign up / Log in

using narrative framework with adolescents

H

Hi there, came across this forum and really glad that I did as it sounds incredibly helpful. I am undertaking my Phd exploring the lives of adolescents who slef harm within the context of their life stories. I would like to engage with other students who are or have used a narrative framework with children or adolescents using in-depth interviews incorporating other creative means of the young person's choice to support them in sharing their story.

I am also interested in hearing back from students as to what narrative framework they found most helpful in analysing the oral narratives obtained from children/adolescents. I came across Riley and Hawe (2005) and liked it as it had a step by step approach eventhough I am finding the steps difficult to interpret!!.

Step 1: Examine narrative segments (sentences and paragraphs) focusing on whether they are descriptive, consequential, evaluative or transformative in nature
Step 2: Focus on why the story is being told the way it is i.e. examine the narrative text in terms of the types of words chosen by the adolescent. How do they decribe events or actions
Step 3: Examine the story telling occassion. In doing so locate ourselves as researchers in the process of narrative construction. Are we only being made privy to some stories and not others? Why? When? Are some stories completed in different contexts?
Step 4, Explore how the process of meaning making interacts with broader institutional or cultural norms or events. What stories are difficult to tell due to tacitly understood processes of social sanctioning?
Step 5: Identify the point of the story. Identify the sequence of events and evaluations that create the direction and form of the plot.

I feel that I could go straight to step 5! If anyone has any guidance in using a narrative framework outside of thematic analysis I would really love your assistance. I was informed that i could not use thematic analysis but i feel that part of a narrative analysis is thematic without fragmenting the story too much

My study has been so complicated in gaining ethical approval for the use of an unstructured approach and also in recruiting young people from services/. The discourse of perceived vulnerability far outweighs the rights of children and adolescents to have a voice and share their perspectives so that we can have a better understanding of their lives in order to determine better responses and interventions. I have worked through a mountain of challenges and would like to try and not make the analysis so complicated as well.

I would really appreciate any advice on analysing the narratives. Its interesting that most papers I read usung a narrative framework use thematic analysis but I am being discouraged from using this.

Help! Help! Help!
Eilis

Look forward to some helpful comments

20377