Egoestic Examiners

P

======= Date Modified 23 Sep 2011 14:32:57 =======
I stumbled on this forum and find the discussions very useful. This is my first contribution or better still request for advice.

I have been pursuing a PHD in humanities. My ride has been full of bumps and slums and just when I thought the end of near and bright something else came up.

I submitted some four months ago. When the examiner's reports came back, while two of the examiners were very impressed with the thesis as expressed in their remarks and the fact that the both awarded a pass of above 75 each (not that it matters). The third examiner did not fail nor passed the thesis but asked for a resubmit on grounds that there is no strong link between the thesis and the discipline in which I would be awarded the degree. Furthermore authors in their discipline have not been acknowledged.

The situation in my country is that we do not do a viva. However, all three examiners must pass the thesis.

Elaborating the strong link as expressed by the third examiner she/he simply means that why award you a degree in marketing while your topic is more human resources inclined. However, the situation is not my making in that a PHD is not offered in human resources for instance and my proposal was accepted for the said degree.

My supervisors reaction:
The main supervisor was very furious and decided to call the examiner. From their discussion, the examiner expressed the need to preserve their discipline.

Suggested solution:
The second examiner suggests that we insert a new chapter defining stuff and end by linking these to the research theme.

The main supervisor however thinks we should leave everything the same the but at the same time through in a few catch words to appease the said examiner.

I am worried. I believe fully accommodating this examiner would mean a change in topic, research problem and objects which I find practically impossible at this stage.

The worst case scenario is that the third examiner fails me. What options do I have should that happen.

I keep my fingers cross as I meet my supervisors for a possible line of action.


Any advice on how to handle my situation is helpful.
Thanks in advance
polo



20575