Has the decision about corrections already been taken before viva take places ?

K

Is it true or not that in reality, the decision about corrections has already been taken in advance of the exam and the viva itself very rarely influences or alters that decision ?

K

My supervisor told me that the decision will not be made before viva and the viva will affect a lot to indicate that I will be awarded or not.

W

One of my friends recently completed his PhD and afterwards his examiners made it pretty clear that his viva performance was the reason he only got minor corrections (3 months) rather than major corrections. This is because he didn't include a discussion of some particular literature that they felt was important (he hadn't felt that it was relevant when writing his thesis). Because he could talk about it in the viva and explain the main issues they knew he understood it, hence less work to do.

I suppose on some occassions it might be decided before (i.e. it's a clear cut case) but I would suggest the viva is usually pretty important.

5662