How to Handle Disagreement with Direction of Manuscript

01-May-12, 07:12
Avatar for StrawberryTea
posted about 8 years ago
Any advice would be greatly appreciated...

I am actually not a PhD student but a medical resident... but I feel that the awesome people on this forum could shed some light on my situation. I am writing a review paper with a senior resident (I'm a junior resident) and staff. I wrote the whole thing, sent it to the senior for editing, and she has cut out 50%+ of the manuscript.

I am willing to shorten the paper, but feel that this is a bit excessive. Unfortunately the senior is unwilling to meet me halfway... I disagree with the present state of the paper (I don't think it makes much sense now) to the point that I do not feel comfortable being the first author and being accountable for its current content.

My staff is extremely nice but to be honest I'm not even sure if she has read the paper or not.

Any suggestions?

Thank you
01-May-12, 08:38
edited about 3 seconds later
Avatar for DrJeckyll
posted about 8 years ago
I have recently attended a ' how to write a paper' course. The guy adviced as to target for a specific journal. Then analyse 5 or 6 published papers. I had never noticed, but all of them had the same number of words in the title, the same structure and similar amount of words in each section. Agree with your senior where you are publishing and stick to the journal's template.

Good luck ! :)
01-May-12, 11:27
Avatar for Hypothesis
posted about 8 years ago
It's always a pain to see someone do a hatchet job on your hard work. However, in most cases this is for a good reason - my advice would be: "listen to their experience; politely enquire why this needs to be removed - state your case for keeping it; keep an objective head"


Copyright ©2018
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

PostgraduateForum is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, 77 Sidney St, Sheffield, S1 4RG, UK. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766