Overview of Pjlu

Overview

Avatar for Pjlu
Pjlu 4 star member
Tuesday, 22 December 2009 at 8:10pm
Sunday, 23 April 2017 at 12:55pm
999
Login to send a private message to Pjlu
page 1 of 44 recent posts

Thread: Feedback on your work

posted
28-Apr-17, 08:58
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 12 hours ago
Quote From Tudor_Queen:
I'd find it rather annoying too. It seems a bit silly to me... I like honest and face-to-face feedback, but I'd rather they spent the hour reading it and outlining several clear bullet points of feedback / or else give 5 minutes of clear verbal feedback.

Also I think referring to "her" or "him" when the person is sat in the room is incredibly rude! Even if it is saying "she's done a good job". We're humans not dogs! I think I find this kind of thing less acceptable from having worked and been treated with respect in the workplace before doing a PhD.

I think my point is - there's a difference between honest, critical, and face-to-face feedback and being rude.


Hi Tudor Queen, thanks. I smiled when I read your comment. To clarify though, I have really nice supervisors who are very busy. The second supervisor who is the Head of School supervises many PhD students and I'm lucky when I do get to meet with her. I think they were arguing over some changes, and while I sat there, I guess I learned a couple of things.

Even highly educated and experienced supervisors who get on very well, will read and interpret your work quite differently and want you to write in different ways.

They were so engrossed in arguing the point about whatever it was I had written, that they forgot about me and were just intent on working through the issue. In retrospect, it is rather funny, although at the time I was a bit annoyed.

The second supervisor who I barely see and is always very busy has a 100 percent track record of getting her PHD students through so I am really keen to get her advice, and value the short periods of time I get to see her. It's excruciating to sit through sometimes but very useful.

Thread: Missed Retake Exam

posted
27-Apr-17, 09:10
edited about 2 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 day ago
Given you were admitted to hospital, there would be a staff member at the hospital (resident doctor) who saw you and can provide a certificate for your time in the hospital-at least to state that you were admitted from X o'clock, treated by Dr such and such and left the hospital at Y o'clock? Your general practitioner (regular doctor) should also be able to provide a certificate that states that you were advised to report to hospital. And the supervisor from the university should be able to back this up. This might be enough to convince the department, or provide evidence to support a formal claim or appeal?

Best wishes, sounds like it was a pretty awful experience to undergo. Hope things work out...

Thread: (PhD Report) Is this a minor correction, major, or revise and resubmit?

posted
26-Apr-17, 10:24
edited about 17 minutes later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 2 days ago
It sort of sounds like major corrections but perhaps not revise and resubmit. If your advisor thinks it can be done in a month, then perhaps it is just a case of a big final edit. It reads as though all of the material is in there but perhaps obscured by too much material and detail.

Some people love reading rich, highly textured and detailed texts, others prefer leaner, sparser material that shows the 'bones' in a more logical manner.

Thread: Survey Monkey - a credible tool at PhD level?

posted
25-Apr-17, 21:59
edited about 14 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 2 days ago
Not to put down survey monkey as a tool.

However, if you are considering different tools or other options, you might look at Qualtrics. This tool is a professional surveying and data producing instrument used by my faculty and university. I think it has free trial options as well if this helps. It really was excellent and very professional-had many different functions and options.

You might also see whether your faculty or university have an institutional membership to a specific tool or instrument that you could use.

Thread: Emailing potential PhD supervisor

posted
25-Apr-17, 00:46
edited about 8 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 3 days ago
Sorry about your name misspelling by the way, I've tried to correct this-but for some reason not working!

Thread: Emailing potential PhD supervisor

posted
25-Apr-17, 00:45
edited about 41 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 3 days ago
Hi Emery, do they keep hours available for student, and research student face to face advice? If so, email to ask whether you could make a time to catch up briefly and address questions in person might be a good way to proceed. A 20 minute conversation would be the equivalent of of several thousand words in an email. Sometimes making that personal connection helps if you are looking to establish an ongoing relationship. Good luck with your application.

Thread: Feeling intimidated/bullied by my supervisor

posted
24-Apr-17, 20:37
edited about 10 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 4 days ago
Hi Bluesky, to be honest, this situation sounds like a really valid reason for seeking a new supervisor. I don't think the Facebook post and thread situation is acceptable in any workplace (from either supervisor, colleague, or any direct reports), even if it doesn't specify you personally.

Who can you raise this with at the university, because I think you would have grounds for a complaint or filing a grievance. Are you sure you can't request another supervisor or do you have a second supervisor or panel who would be of some assistance here. if this doesn't seem possible, there must be a HR, administrative support service or counselling service that might help with providing an official pathway forward that would be appropriate for your university. I'm sorry I can't be of more help. Your post, I would think, indicates that your supervisor really has a problem. Best of luck. I am sure that others might have more specific and pertinent advice they can give.

Thread: Library membership-journal access for members not working in academia post PhD?

posted
21-Apr-17, 02:02
edited about 58 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 week ago
Off today for the 90 minute drive to enrol in the main public library for the region-different from my very little local one-it also requires a separate membership.

@Bewildered, I'll talk to my current uni library on my next trip interstate to see what they can do for me. I don't mind paying extra fees and I will chat to my supervisors in my (hopefully) final meeting before submission. While I have presented posters and at conferences and I am sure I will get some publications from this, (I can envisage at least 3), I don't think I will be illustrious enough to get anything special. I am sort of one of those 'good-reliable-solid' producers of knowledge-not what I would consider is a star in faculty terms. The supervisors seem to like my thesis though and are very encouraging-but it isn't what you would call 'sexy research' if there was such a thing! (lol).

If they don't offer much more than what appears on their website (limited journal access), I will research into an ongoing paid subscription into one of the major universities here-and I will check out all the online stuff. I'm a member of research gate already, which is great. Cheers and many thanks BC, Zao and Bewildered-P

Thread: Final year support thread

posted
20-Apr-17, 08:04
edited about 41 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 week ago
Today I emailed off a copy of my full draft to both supervisors, who plan to read it over the next month and then let me know:

a. whether I can file my intention to submit in 8 weeks form with my faculty
b. what else really has to be done or altered

I still have to chase up on some references, write the acknowledgement, place in appendices, and my list of tables and figures and redraft and format 3 or 4 tables on pdfs that need to inserted on Word rather than as pdfs (bit hard to fit them in).

So I plan to do this over the next few weekends after work, and then will fly over for what I hope is the final big meeting.

It is a surreal feeling-still things to do but so close now. Fingers crossed any changes the supervisors suggest will be minor ones.

Thread: Not so clean colleagues ?

posted
20-Apr-17, 07:52
edited about 4 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 week ago
Charliebrown is A a senior with regard to his/her rank or just age and time spent in the department?

Can you ask your previous head the one with the stock reply 'I do not have those files' to spend around 30 minutes or so with you to nut out the basic outlines of each course or program. Or perhaps if you spend a weekend thinking, planning and drawing up some outlines, then meet with him to get his perspective on what you think would be okay and to comment on the programs-then go ahead and start the process of filing the programs and slowly fleshing them out. Can you delegate resourcing of outlines out to other part-timers-some of the more helpful ones perhaps?

Sounds to me like A is someone you are going to need to 'go around' but not in an antagonistic way-more of a just get on with it and then let him in on things on an 'as needs basis'. (This might be really annoying personally because A really does need to get his/her act together-however, it seems unlikely that this will happen anytime soon, so best to go to plan B in this case).

With regard to marks and assessment records-that's pretty serious mismanagement and this is surely not just down to you to fix up. Who helps or sorts out the admin side of things with this sort of stuff-they must be pretty frustrated with all of this as well (unless they are really lazy or inefficient)? They might be able to be an ally and help you introduce some basic processes for filing, recording and keeping central copies of programs. Do you have any supportive seniors? If it is really this bad, then they need to know just how lacking it really is...

(NB-My experience is in educational secondary ed 7-12 though not post secondary level. However I've inherited dodgy departments and practices in my different roles in secondary schools over the years- I hope this helps, even with some moral support if nothing else.)

Thread: Library membership-journal access for members not working in academia post PhD?

posted
19-Apr-17, 09:12
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 week ago
Great advice and responses people-thank you!! Really appreciate the responses and will follow up on tips.

Thread: Library membership-journal access for members not working in academia post PhD?

posted
18-Apr-17, 00:23
edited about 1 minute later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 week ago
I'm not sure my title describes this accurately but what I am trying to ask is what options are people taking for journal and library access once they have completed their PhD and/or for those who are not going the post-doc or academic employment pathway?

My alumni benefits (once I have completed) offers only limited library benefits and no online journal access. I'm pretty sure others would have similar experiences. I know I will want access to knowledge and journals plus I now live at a distance, having recently moved to a small country town for a particular job (and will stay here for a couple of years before I move to a bigger centre again). What are other people doing?

I do pay for membership to professional associations in education but their journal access is pretty much limited to their in house journals.

Anyone currently in or about to go into this situation with ideas, plans or good advice they would like to share? Thanks :)

Thread: Stuck and fed-up, and the perfect situation

posted
17-Apr-17, 06:35
edited about 28 minutes later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 1 week ago
Hi Milo, I understand that you are concerned regarding formal deadlines and how having one might exacerbate anxiety or trigger some issues but have you considered that not having one might also increase your anxiety.

Right now the situation you describe has you in a sort of limbo-family living elsewhere to help out, no discernible deadline in sight. Do you think that it might help to work out some realistic deadlines with your supervisors, or your wife, support counsellors (whoever it is who you talk to who helps with this sort of stuff) even though you are worried about this?

(Without trying to minimise your feelings in any way), with some support and a bit of a plan you might be able to grit your teeth and work through the @11#y feelings for short periods of time. Acknowledge the feelings-not minimise or ignore them- but keep to some daily targets and rewards as Big Problems has suggested to help you get through them.

What I have found also is that once you have a realistic but definite deadline to work towards, momentum increases-not because you are enjoying it or intrinsically motivated but because you can see the endpoint (unless of course you are worried about completing...and that lies beyond your anxiety perhaps??).

Thread: Quitting PhD

posted
13-Apr-17, 02:58
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 2 weeks ago
My experience has been that detailed feedback that addresses issues in any depth are only forthcoming at the later or final stages of writing. The PhD is a journey that is considered to be largely independent so responsibility for growth and development is largely on oneself.

I can understand your claim or statement though that if you get limited feedback early on, it is harder. And the quality of supervision is probably uneven. There would be amazing supervisors out there who just really inspire, but I think most of us have 'good enough' supervisors just like we have 'good enough' parents, etc (borrowing a concept from Winnecott). Good luck with it all-it is a tough process and some people (perhaps like yourself) do have it a bit tougher than others unfortunately.

Thread: Final year support thread

posted
08-Apr-17, 22:01
edited about 20 seconds later
by Pjlu 4 star member
Avatar for Pjlu
posted about 2 weeks ago
Quote From Hindsightless:
Hello Everyone,

I submitted my MSc by Research thesis (25,000 words) 23.01.2017 and still haven't received my results. Just wondered what the average time to receive the results/award is? My experience at this university was not a good one and I'm concerned that they might fail me. Any advice while I sit, wait and worry?

Thanks in advance,

Steven.

Hi there Steven, a few years ago I completed my MEd by Research of Thesis (same length). I submitted it in September 2010 and received the examiner's marks in mid March 2011 to graduate officially in April 2011. I can't remember the actual dates now. It was longer than it should have been and I am not sure why but I think it might have had something to do finding examiners and then once they had them, the examiners had two quite different scores and needed to agree on what the final outcome would be. The outcome was good and the thesis was accepted with no need for revision or change.

The length of time does not mean that you will have failed-universities are large beasts and often move slowly. It can take a long time to go through all of the various checkpoints. If you are worried contact the university's research admin officer or your supervisor and ask how it is going. They should be able to reassure you or move things along if necessary. Well done on your submission and good luck!
page 1 of 44 recent posts

Postgraduate
Forum

Copyright ©2011
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

FindA University Ltd, Sellers Wheel, 151 Arundel Street, Sheffield, S1 2NU, United Kingdom. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766