Overview of eng77

Recent Posts

Looking for failed PhD students willing to give it another shot! Motivation Group!
E

My field of work is engineering.

Looking for failed PhD students willing to give it another shot! Motivation Group!
E

Calling ourselves "failed" PhD students does not look motivating. I am a former PhD student who have not completed a PhD. I am happy to join your support group but not necessarily with the goal to pursue a PhD again.

PhD Appeal in a British University
E

Congratulations Kareem. You made it. It might have been a pain to go through appeal but it is worth. Congratulations

E

When people are born and raised healthy, in most cases they do not realise how others that born with a disability suffer. This is also the case when postgraduate students from a "developing" country suffer, most EU students have no idea of how they see things.
Born in such country is a huge unseen disability. What are your chances if you want to do postgraduate study and research in "real" institutions? What are your chances to get a decent job utilising your education and skills?
You have to go to the formalities and pay the international tuition fees. One goal for most "international" postgraduate students is to continue living in the country they study at.
Actually they search for new home. They have a target to achieve. They want to get a residence permit then a permanent residence permit then a citizenship to match a "normal" person who was born in the EU, Canada or Australia. I recall a conversation with a PhD student and I asked him if he got the citizenship of the country of the university, he replied unfortunately no. He said citizenship is more important than PhD! I do not agree with him but I would also say getting a EU citizenship is "equivalent" or close to the same achievement of obtaining a PhD.
I do not have any solution or suggestion but I wanted to highlight some troubles that are not usually seen by healthy people.

Post-doc reference, part II
E

Quote From Jamie_Wizard:

I think I should move to a country like Germany, Switzerland or Austria where day-to-day things seem to be handled more efficiently (and their chocolate is pretty good too :-)

I am living now in one of these countries after spending reasonable time in the UK. Do NOT ever think of it. For a change for a year or so, it is OK. But you cannot imagine how bureaucracy here is. You cannot imagine paperwork and stamps. You can get 3 or 4 stamps on a single document. They worship rules and systems. They put rules over people. Even job reference system works differently. Some companies require a formal letter from your last employers evaluating your qualities. The letter is written in a "coded" way to say you are good, OK, or bad.
Another side remark, if there is a paradise on earth, it is the UK, a fact that I realised too late unfortunately.

To get to know a PhD supervisor signing up under him
E

Quote From pm133:
sashank, here are my thoughts which are purely based on your post.
You forgot to interview your supervisor.
You should have asked him what he expected of you, how frequently he would want to meet up, what support he was going to provide and what he expected you to figure out yourself, what hours he wanted you working, who would write any papers resulting from your work, how long would he expect you to take to graduate and what would happen if you took longer, who would provide support when he wasnt there and a whole host of other questions.
Dont feel bad, its an inexperience thing.

Maybe you were too desperate to get a big name or a big uni on your CV to the point that you lost objectivity. People make these sorts of mistakes all the time.

Its promising that you are even asking the question.

What is your gut feeling telling you that you should do now to fix things?

I believe this is very helpful for me in future job interviews.
So rewriting for a non-academic job:
- What is expected from me?
- How frequent would I meet with line manager?
- What kind of (non) technical support would I get? and what things do I have to take care on my own without expecting support?
- How many hours would I be expected to show up at office? is it possible to work remotely sometimes? is there flexibility?
- Like usually asked by interviewers, where do you see yourself in 5 years. Where do you see "me" in 5 years?
- How a typical working day look like?

Looking for advice
E

Quote From emaa:
I will do👍🏻Is it normal to send emails to universities or proffersors working in my field to ask an advice or offer a volunteer job 🤔

Some people would see it abnormal but I see it differently. We all are human and this is human to human communication. What are going to lose? Professors might not reply/stop replying for potential PhD/Postdocs with no reason which I find "impolite". The worst that could happen is they ignore your email which will leave you with the same outcome if you do not send it :)

Post-doc reference, part II
E

Quote From Jamie_Wizard:

I don't know why I get myself into such a frenzy of catastrophising, oh dear.

I have the same problem when something is very important to me, I feel bad and worried when others do not put it in their priorities. I know I am wrong but this behaviour might be caused from bad experience where things were slowed down by others to the limit that eventually were not done at all.

Looking for advice
E

Quote From emaa:
it is frustrating to restart from zero in a new country

Again I know exactly how you feel. Have you also considered universities in 200 km radius? for example in NL or DE?

Looking for advice
E

Hello. There is no golden advice I am afraid. What I recommend is to send to PIs showing interest even in volunteer jobs to put a foot in the lab. Moreover, have you considered the Flemish part of Belgium? Commute from Brussels won't be that far and English is totally accepted there in contrast to the French Belgium.

Post-doc reference, part II
E

I know exactly how you feel. A typical HR behaviour. They usually think they have more important things to do. Just call him/her again tomorrow or so and be a bit "pushy". I do not think there is any bad intentions, but only careless behaviour.

Being sick and turning up late for my PhD
E

This is bullshit. If your university in Europe, you should be firm about your health problem with supervisor and even report his behaviour. About this a**hole RA, be more firm and tell him you have a boss to talk to and it is not his business to decide for you what time to show up at office.
Now the scary part if you are in one the countries where oppression and forced labour are not uncommon, then talk to supervisor and tell him it is not possible to do this and you spend 8 or 9 hours nevertheless at work. Tell him about this bullying RA and get this thing clear and understood that you won't go everyday to work with fear.
Otherwise quitting is still an option. I do not see any good coming from this environment if things stayed the same.

PhD finance
E

Hi. I am sorry to do that. I would advise you to change the degree as soon as possible to Master by research or taught Master. Otherwise it is more likely you won't get anything and exit with nothing.

Bewildered and confused by supervisor
E

I would like to add that my ex supervisor hates the most when someone gives him a paper which requires a lot of proof reading or incomplete figures. He usually said go to peer colleagues and give me the paper in a state that it needs only fine tuning. You are right. The situation is not ideal but it is not that bad. He/she should have reacted better but it is still not very bad.

Does the ranking of the university matter for PhD?
E

Ranking matters but not very much. Ranking matters more when you want to go further in academia. If you work in academia, publications are more important than ranking. If you work outside academia, ranking does not play a great role.
Nevertheless I do not agree with those employers who based their choice solely on ranking and publications but it is how it works in most of the academia world.