Overview of GUEST

Recent Posts

phd funding
G

hi,..i am a student from underdeveloped country..i have phd offer from Cambridge but due to lack of funding i deffered last years offer to this year..but i have not got any funding till now...does anyone have any idea about any fundings..??? thx a lot in advance

phd / dphil difference
G

what is the difference between a phd and a dphil? & why do doctorates have so many different names?

Desperately seeking advice!
G

Hi Simon, it's a shot in the dark but also, maybe your friend could make the most of the other academics in her department that she worked with (or even those who knew her and her work)? Maybe the level of supervision she needs at the latter stages of her PhD, she could approach someone else in her department even if it was just the occasional email? In any case, I would do what Ann suggested. I hope it works out for her!

How important is supervision in a PhD?
G

...Also, speaking with your supervisor as regularly as possible not only helps you to establish a rapport with them, but the intellectual process of discussing things helps with developing your skills as a scientist/researcher. That isn't to say that you should be knocking on their door every 5 minutes; coffee breaks or a pint at lunchtime I find are good opportunities!

Desperately seeking advice!
G

If the Uni can see that your friend is still motivated and keen to complete and that her progress has been hampered through no fault of her own, I'm sure they will do all they can to help (especially considering part of her problem has been inadequate supervision). I think the key thing is to let the Uni know the situation without further delay. Best wishes.

How important is supervision in a PhD?
G

I feel that having a supervisor who is readily available (and approachable) is important to me personally. I both benefit and enjoy having someone with whom to discuss thoughts and ideas -not only about the experimental aspects of my work, but also with the theory. Even if the discussion topics aren't directly related to the project, they are still in some ways useful.

How important is supervision in a PhD?
G

I prefer a supervisor that I don't know is there. In other words, one that is around and I can bounce ideas off, but that I don't feel like they are breathing down my neck. I don't really get on with my postdoc as she is just the opposite to that, but luckily there is another one I can talk to. Oh, and I only have one supervisor!

decisions, decisions
G

I'm in a similar situation and unsure what to do. I recently had an interview for a PhD studentship and one of the supervisors promised the department would reimburse my travel expenses, amounting to £250 as the interview was a short airjourney away. To my surprise, I was offered the studentship almost on the spot. However, I'm waiting to hear back from another, potentially better project. Can the department ask me to pay back the reimbursed expenses, if I turn down their offer?

Desperately seeking advice!
G

Thanks for the reply Ann, it's appreciated. My friend was given a years extension about 9 months back so I have no idea if she could get a further extension.

Desperately seeking advice!
G

Hi Simon
Your friend needs to contact the research degrees committee at her institution. They should be able to help her with both problems i.e. ensure that she has adequate supervision (by appointing another supervisor for her if necessary) and perhaps by granting her an extension on her PhD deadline (they will usually be very supportive if a student genuinely has personal problems). She needs to talk to someone ASAP, people can only help when they are aware of the situation. I hope it all works out for her.

Desperately seeking advice!
G

I have a friend who is 3 months away from a deadline on her PhD thesis. Due to personal circumstances she had to return to Canada from England where she was studying. She had 2 supervisors, one disappeared off to a new job in Australia and the other one seems to barely offer any support at all. She's stressed out and frustrated that she's getting no support when she needs it and seemingly has no avenues to turn to. As a non academic myself I really have no idea how to help her, but I'm really looking for any avenues/forums/support groups/suggestions of any kind - anything that could be of help. I realise part of her problem is that she's away from the university she was studying at, but there's nothing she can do about that. If anyone has any suggestions or advice I'd be really grateful.

stinking interview questions
G

If there is something in your cv which is not so great have a reason for this ready, and be honest. I took to long for my degree and told my suporvisor why it took longer.

stinking interview questions
G

"How have you overcome difficulties in the past"

"Explain what you did for your masters"

Then I was asked if I knew that the pay wasn't going to be too great.

Read through their papers carefully, and, if possible make a comment on their work. Just show, that you've been intersted enough to see what they work on.
Ask them, how many PhD students they have had up to date. Request to speak to the other members of the lab, if possible without the supervisor.

How important is supervision in a PhD?
G

you will need a good supervisor if things go wrong and you need to troubleshoot an experiment that won't work for you. Having people around that can give you advice (with much experiance themselves) can really help if you are at the end of your own whits. So it is always good to have some experianced postdocs in the lab you can talk to - or a good supervisor.

Ph.D from japan, korea...
G

But how is the quality of research & teaching quantified? Is there an equivalent of our RAE exercises? As for resources and funding, what specifically makes Japanese institutions some of the best in the world over others? What is actually meant by this statement that they are amongst the best in the world? - Given that every country has its different style of higher education with its pros and cons, I'm wondering if it's a rather sweeping comparison to make.