Overview of GUEST

Recent Posts

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

The reasoning I was given off my boss is that they cant have a graduate in charge of another graduate or god forbid a phd. And as for higher research positions - they would rather have a phd level scientist on graduate salaries (which are significantly less than phd salaries).

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

I know this to be the case from my experience too. I really can't see the logic behind it at all; why would anyone need to be trained in research to perform a managerial job? Surely for such positions within industry, it works better for the company and the employee if they have worked within the company for X number of years first. Furthermore, it really does add to students' burdens not only during their studenthood because longer study = a higher debt, but also when they are trying to establish a worthwhile career that pays accordingly.

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

You need a phd t get anywhere in industry. I know from expereince. I thought i could work my way up too but it didnt matter how good at my job i was - they would rather have a phd for the higher positions esp. management.

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

The original intended use of the PhD programme was to prepare people for their careers in research. Nowadays however there seem to be more and more people with PhD's going into jobs outside of academia for which they could perform without a PhD. This is because there are more (bachelors) degree graduates every year than there are graduate jobs available.

pharmaceutical sciences
G

i am a Ph. D. Student of j.s.s. college of pharmacy, ootacamund-643001, tamilnadu, india. i am doing my Ph. D. in opthalmic drug delivery systems in treatment of glaucoma. so please guide me for schlorship or please give me information the companies which offer such schlorships.

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

I thought that one of the reasons for doing a phd was to get a better career prospects. My undersatnding is that you can reach a certain glass celing if you don't have a phd esp in academia. If u work in industry do you need a phd for the more responsible jobs or can u work your way up?

University reputations
G

I kinda managed to get a postdoc position without having a PhD at St Andrews Uni for 3 years. Giving recent comments about RAE on an internal mailling list, Paisleys higher ranking than them wasn't too well received. ;) I think it matters somehow, depending on the intelligence of your future employer. For the more arrogant it will certainly matter. A decent academic will look at what you have done and not where. Probably not worth being with people that rate place over content.

Your supervisors first PhD student
G

Hi,

I wanted to know if there are any other PhD's students out there, who were the first PhD student of their supervisor?

I just passed 2 days ago my PhD pending some changes. So I am quite delighted but also a bit disappointed. It was quite an ordeal, especially at the beginning, where my supervisor was very insecure flipping at every comment one of his lecturer pals made, resulting in making me quite insecure.

How good (academically) does your supervisor expect you to be?
G

I found my supervisor did not know, what I should know. I ended up in a weird requirement being mature, yet british kindergarten.

Value/Purpose of Phds
G


I think the value in doing a PhD is personal. It allows you to broaden your intellect, and increase exponentially your knowledge in a subject you enjoy. You are also able to contribute and give something back to an institution you like.
While your advisors are obviously complimenting your abilities, if it doesn't immediately grab you there is possibly no point in trying to find merits for a PhD

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

I felt quite disheartened when I saw the results of the other poll on this website. It's incredibly sad I think that people feel as if they have to have a PhD to place themselves ahead of the rest of the field, when in the past, a bachelors degree would have done the same job. An example: the father of someone I used to know, who would be in his 50's, with an ordinary bachelors degree he landed himself a career with a major chemical firm and the result of which is that he is fairly loaded with cash now. But what would an ordinary degree get you nowadays? A silly MacDonalds uniform maybe? Quite unfair when you consider how much hard work and sacrifice goes into a first degree let alone a PhD. Can someone please tell me why the government intends that 50% of school-leavers to go into university education. It helps who exactly?

Value/Purpose of Phds
G

A couple of my tutors suggested I ought to do a postgraduate course - MA and/or PhD (Art/design related). It may be something I consider doing in the future, but I often wondered what is the value/purpose in doing a PhD?

Why won't they respond?
G

Hi Bicycle Repair Man
I just phoned the supervisor's direct line and asked about the project one lunch time at work. I was really suprised how responsive she was. I too was really worried that I would appear too pushy, but then I think thats what they want.
I just asked what the project was, what background they were looking for and thats really it... she did most of the talkng.
After having spoken to my supervisor, she offered me an interview, and as we already had spoken, this was much more enjoyable than others I've had!

Age Matters
G

This age thing seems to be a problem everywhere ( or so I read).
I am 32 and want to get back to academics, do a masters and then possibly a PhD. Have good work experience related to my research interests.
Would you say I would be risking my livelihood if I get back to studies till say I'm 38? My field would be signal processing.
What exactly is the situation regarding mature age PhDs?

MRes
G

I am thinking of applying to study in Manchester Uni they have Mres degree courses. Do they give you a better advantage than the MSC degree courses.