Overview of pm133

Recent Posts

Major advice needed
P

Your 2:2 is certainly a problem both from the perspective of getting accepted onto a PhD course and also your ability to cope with the PhD successfully. A postgrad masters degree is the easiest way to fix that.

People do get onto PhD programs with a 2:2 but my personal opinion is that this simply devalues a process which should be preserved for the most academically gifted people. The PhD is the pinnacle of academic achievement. Preparing your base camp properly with a good masters degree is commonsense really so I think you have the right idea here.
You should experience no problems whatsoever getting onto a Masters course as far as I know but oers may have a different opinion.

Go for it and good luck.

Advice for a Struggling Postdoc?
P

It sounds to me like you are making the classic mistakes of both setting your expectations too highly and chasing impact factors and publications instead of focussing solely on the research. The former follows the latter.

I would take a step back and re-evaluate your approach and expectations of your career at this point. If you focus too much on the ends you risk destroying the means.

A postdoc is no different to industrial employment. In both games you need to achieve measureable success or you will struggle but if you continually try to visualise "lifting the cup" (as advised by bogus "motivational coaches" everywhere) you run the very real risk of psyching yourself out and being knocked out in the first round. Focus on the day to day stuff and set smaller targets. You should start by recognising that your PhD publication record is now irrelevant to your current situation. The impact factor thing is certainly not helpful right now.

PhD thesis minor corrections
P

Minor changes means the external doesnt need to see or approve your changes.
Simply argue away the things you wont be changing.
I didnt change every single comment either. I suspect most of us will do the same thing.

Almost written up, but feeling trapped
P

I am a little confused here.
Why would you think it was your supervisor's choice what job you took and when you took it?
Just accept the job and let your supervisor know you will be leaving on a specific date. Do the thesis changes in your spare time.
Absolutely no reason to feel trapped.

Career options outside academia
P

Look into current jobs for data analysis, figure out what skills are required and set about acquiring those skills in your spare time.
Once you feel you have some competence then start applying for jobs. That is how I have operated in the past.
You may already have enough skill anyway. Nothing is lost by sending in a CV to a few jobs and finding out.

Business cards (PhD fresh grad)
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
I don't know, but there is a difference between dressing nicely in general (what I said) and turning up somewhere dressed smartly when everyone else is casual (what you said). The latter is probably going to be painful, whereas the former is common sense when one wants to make a good impression. My point is: putting an effort in can go a long way. For instance, when a presenter at a conference is well dressed (smartly or nicely or whatever you want to call it), in my view, it forms part of their overall presentation. And, in my own subjective view, a business card is along similar lines - can be quite impressive.


I am still not sure what you mean in terms of the difference between dressing nicely and dressing smartly but I appear to have gravely offended yet another in a long line of tedious snowflakes in butterfly20 who can't handle a simple difference of opinion in a reasonable manner. This really is a modern day scourge. I have no wish to waste my time on this type of person so I will bail from the discussion.

Business cards (PhD fresh grad)
P

Quote From butterfly20:
What a load of shite, dressing nicely reeks of desperation!


Jeez!

Business cards (PhD fresh grad)
P

Quote From butterfly20:
Sorry, I was agreeing with you. And disagreeing with the person who said dressing smartly reeks of desperation. I’ve never heard such rubbish. Keynote speakers wear suits most of the time. Id hardly call people in that position desperate.


Deary me. A couple of us are having a friendly exchange of ideas and you barge in with these immature two posts?
Sort yourself out and come back when you are prepared to be civil..

PhD application. Do I stand a chance of a funded PhD in Biosciences?
P

Quote From Michael65:
Well for my master`s I had a 4 month research project in the labs for the dissertation module, and that went on from May last year until August. I was hoping that this experience could boost my application despite having quite average grades.

My BSc was from a top 50 non-RG uni also, I don`t know how much that will go against me.


It will make no meaningful difference. I would be surprised if anyone knows what a "top 50 non RG uni" actually means anyway.

Business cards (PhD fresh grad)
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
Well... I don't think I said anything about turning up smart when everyone else is dressed casual... that would just be awkward. I just said about dressing really nicely. And yep, I do think it can be good thing. In fact - I know it can! Impressions and appearances count at times.


What is the difference between dressing smartly and dressing really nicely?

Business cards (PhD fresh grad)
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
This is quite a subjective topic. You think that dressing nicely at a conference reeks of desperation, others do not (myself included - and I am also older and have good bit of experience). For some, dressing up may be part of their "presence" and work very well for them. At the same time, I agree that following the lead of others is a good way to go. It sounds as though having a card may be the done thing in LeslieM's circles, and so perhaps she is seeking to do what is the norm / has paid off / worked well for others in her field.


Yes it is subjective and when it comes to dressing up for a conference when most turn up in casual wear, yes I do believe that reeks of desperation. You are of course welcome to have a different opinion. I wouldn't suggest otherwise.

The only opinions which matter are those who are hiring. What do they look for? If it's a business card and a suit then it's a no brainer. Personally i am not convinced it is but maybe I am wrong. Sadly, not many of those hirers tell us which leaves the rest of us tying ourselves in knots trying to second guess.

Assertiveness with supervisor
P

For me it is about moving on with the minimum of fuss. Other people have a duty to fight their own battles. I am responsible for myself, my own future and my own mental health. Usually there is an opportunity to explain to someone more senior why you are leaving and I have always taken the opprtunity to do so in an assertive and crystal clear manner without letting emotion get in the way. Whether they choose to act on that is then their decision.

Of course it depends on the extent and nature of the bullying. For example, I would not allow sexual harassment, which I had personally witnessed, to go unreported but make no mistake, I consider the impact on myself first and foremost.

Business cards (PhD fresh grad)
P

Quote From Tudor_Queen:
I see it as going that extra step and impressive - a bit like the person who dresses really nicely at a conference. I think they stand out in a good way.

Sorry I've just realised that I have ignored your actual questions! So...all personal opinions here (and coming from someone who themselves hasn't got a business card and probably won't ever...)
1) I think you could put the field/expertise here - e.g., mental health researcher ... but personally I would just put name and PhD in X under it.
2) I definitely wouldn't include info about WHERE I got my degrees - that seems unnecessary and would clutter the card
3) Surely this is just down to personal preference, but I prefer the Moo/Momogram design - it's funky yet very professional


Hmmmm dressing "nicely" for a conference also reeks of desperation.
Maybe it's just because I am older and more experienced but I can smell despair at 100 paces.
In my opinion, what gets you noticed is "presence" in a room. No business card or "smart clothes" will be a substitute for that. In my experience, very few PhD students or even post docs have any presence whatsoever. It comes from confidence in yourself and, in turn, that comes from experience.

To see what I am getting at, go to the next conference and try to spot the academics with permanent jobs. Now look at the students and post docs who seem to behave in a manner indistinguishable from the staff. There will only be one or two. My advice is to follow their lead and drop all the other nonsense.

How to report a private message
P

Quote From newlease36:
Can anyone tell me how to report a private message or contact the moderators.

I received a pm from some random troll offering to format my thesis and do referencing.
As if I'm going to hand that over to some anonymous person with no accountability.

I resent being spammed by these circumspect people. . Grr


In all honesty, just press delete.
Life is certainly way too short to be getting annoyed by it.

Assertiveness with supervisor
P

Quote From helebon:
I experienced a time with my supervisor who was a bully. I have since finished the course but feel it would have been useful to have had some urgent training at the time, on being assertive but also being diplomatic. I went to see student support at the uni at the time and they didn't comment on the bullying, either that person was not trained in dealing with the situation or they were closing ranks.

How do other postgrads handle supervisors who are like this? I know bullying is not rare in academia at postgraduate level and you need to be thick-skinned.


I would never "deal" with a bully. I have experienced a few of them and i have always quit and moved elsewhere.

A bully cannot be reasoned with and life is too short to waste. There are too many other opportunities out there.