I just recorded the final report from the doctor school!Now I can 1,quit 2,continue as a mphil 3, mphil.
Can I appeal for a resubmission???its really important for me!please help..

later
by Peachsilk123
Avatar for Peachsilk123
posted about 1 week ago
Hi guys, I’m a first year mphil now.
Our school needs to submit an upgrade work in June to see whether you can upgrade to a PhD.
Today, I got the result that I failed and my supervisor asked me to do a 3 years mphil instead.

However, when I submitted my draft to him, the comment was positive. If he pointed out what I should improve, I whine I can make things right.
Last year, some students can resub it by September. I asked a resub to my supervisor, he rejected again.

Hi, Tru!
Many thanks for your reply. Yes, I think you are right, I’m positively contact other universities now, even if I realized it’s very late now. I spent 3 years to here, but things never happen as my expectation. It’s like a nightmare. But anyway, many thanks, again.

I’m doing art history now, I don’t know whether I can transfer?Another problem is that I went to meet the dean today, he said even if I give an opportunity to you to resub, you cannot pass, and even if you pass this time, you may fail at the PhD stage. I asked why my supervisors didn’t give me a signal or tell me what they want or what I should improve. He said he will see that...what I can do at this stage..

My leading supervisor is the lecturer, but the second supervisor is the dean.
I never got the feedback from the second supervisor. So, this is the current situation. I’m writing an email to the director of doctoral school to appeal a second opportunity. However, I just confused, whether the supervisors have responsibility to point out your shortage when you submit your draft...I just doubted that whether was because he believed I’m not qualified and canny do a PhD, so just told me every was fine?

Hi! Many thanks for your reply. I submioed my first draft to my leading supervisor in the middle of April, and he gave a very positive feedback and pointed out what I should change. According to his opinion, I revised my work and send it the second supervisor, who is the dean of the faculty.but he didn’t reply.
But I was informed yesterday, I need to do a mphil rather than upgrade. They believed my work is not critical enough and not focus on details. However, I think last year, some students got the second opportunity to resub.
I asked my first supervisor yeaster, he rejected a resubmission. I’m quite confused, if he thought I should improve, why he didn’t tell me at the time when I submitted the first draft.

Another problem now is about funding, if I can’t continue, I should refund the money...I’m an international student ... the tuition is really unaffordable...

Hi! Many thanks for your reply. I submitted my first draft to my leading supervisor in the middle of April, and he gave a very positive feedback and pointed out what I should change. According to his opinion, I revised my work and send it the second supervisor, who is the dean of the faculty.but he didn’t reply.
But I was informed yesterday, I need to do a mphil rather than upgrade. They believed my work is not critical enough and not focus on details. However, I think last year, some students got the second opportunity to resub.
I asked my first supervisor yesterday, he rejected a resubmission. I’m quite confused, if he thought I should improve, why he didn’t tell me at the time when I submitted the first draft.

Another problem now is about funding, if I can’t continue, I should refund the money...I’m an international student ... the tuition is really unaffordable...

Hi guys, I’m a first year mphil now.
Our school needs to submit an upgrade work in June to see whether you can upgrade to a PhD.
Today, I got the result that I failed and my supervisor asked me to do a 3 years mphil instead.

However, when I submitted my draft to him, the comment was positive. If he pointed out what I should improve, I whine I can make things right.
Last year, some students can resub it by September. I asked a resub to my supervisor, he rejected again.

I wonder can I argue for a resub???
Help!???!!!!

Hi everyone.
I just got my feedback from my mphil upgrade and unfortunately I failed. I am a first year mphil student now and our school requires us to submit a 20,000 words on May.
Before I submitted my work, I sent the draft to my supervisor and the feedback was positive. However, now he said he believed I cannot continue as a PhD, instead he asked me to do a mphil in three years!
I tried to ask for a resubmission,(this happened last years on some students) and he rejected.
Can I argue again? I just want a resubmission. And if he was unsatisfied with my work, why shouldn’t he tell on draft feedback?

Want help!!!!!
Any ideas????