Overview of donebymonday

Recent Posts

Best Methodology?
D

I feel like a Pearson correlation test is the right one here, but I'm not sure that I can enter data from a dozen call types on a monthly basis in doing that. Any ideas?

Best Methodology?
D

As I further consider, perhaps a time-series analysis is best yet for this?

Best Methodology?
D

Quote From abababa:
This is interestingly close to the crux of how the general public see data vs how researchers see data.

In many glossy lifestyle magazines you'll see 'eating more (or less) red meat reduces cancer risk'. This often refers to a study in which there's a correlation. But as per the cliche collelation does not equal causation; the way a researcher views this data is skeptically (what if people who eat more red meat are also more predisposed to smoking?) .

It sounds a bit like you've been set up with a PhD tied to this intervention to evaluate it. From my experience, this might well mean you have a board of public sector stakeholders who won't go so far as saying they want you to show it did, but probably will be more critical of evidence that shows it didn't. You will thus learn early on navigating these waters as a researcher, which is not an easy task, but a valuable skill. If in the same situation, my first line would probably be to explain that, due to the cofactors, it's not possible to empirically show it 'worked';


Yes! You have indeed brought up many of the concerns I have thought of approaching this. I do recognize this will be limited in its influence. However, I am approaching this as a correlational study, and am not looking for causation. Essentially, the intervention was put into place and a noted politician stated it would not impact the crime rate despite leaving people out of jail. I want to look at the simple response of whether or not there was a notable correlation in that. Would a regression analysis of sorts be most appropriate to accomplish this?

Best Methodology?
D

Quote From Nead:
What software do you plan on using ?
Personally, I would compare the first 6 months of one year with the same 6 months of the next year. Rather than 1 year with a half a year.
THere are helpful guides online like Laerd, minitab has there own guide etc
But it all depends on the software you use.


Hello! I am planning on using SPSS since I had to purchase that previously for a course. It seems quite capable of various types of regression analysis, but I am unsure of what option may be most appropriate.

Best Methodology?
D

Hi all, I'm looking for some suggestions on what the best quantitative methodology may be for a study I am thinking of doing.

I want to compare crime rate between periods of times to see if an intervention implemented by the county impacted crime rate. I am going to compare the number of calls for service and crimes in 2020 to the same in the first six months of 2021. There are about 25 different call types I will be comparing. What kind of regression analysis would be best for this? Thoughts? Thanks!