I definitely think that you should go with the offer which you think is better which seems the second one if you get it. The selection for a PhD position is a process and not only one candidate is selected. There are usually 2-3 candidates who are put as reserves and would be taken if the chosen candidate does not take up the project. It is usually the way to go, and there is no harm in declining an offer and you can let them know the reason. I am sure the department will understand and I don't think there is a question of any black mark or like that. I hope you get the second one as it is the one which you want and will stick with it for the next 3 years! All the Best

Well, I gave for Queen's Uni, Belfast and reading your comments I think I have to be extremely lucky to secure the offer but there seems hope and yes Hazyjane I would def maintain communication with them.

Thanks Dunni73 for sharing your experience!

Hello,

I recently had an interview for a PhD studentship for which I was ranked 2 and informed that if the candidate does not take up the opportunity I could be made an offer. Does anyone share the same experience ? In general should I keep any hope? Few encouraging words would do allot good.

Thanks!