Overview of GUEST

Recent Posts

Why won't they respond?
G

No, on this occasion I had the foresight to put my real name. :)

software engineering
G

Hi, i am completing my masters in software engineering management in uk, my research interest is formal methods. how can i find suitable funded phd in australia. i am an indian national. plzz can anybody guide me.

Why won't they respond?
G

One possible reason - did you sign your email "Bicycle repair man".

Strange People
G

No, no no...this forum should be specified for beginner of Phd student in Britain only. Those who wanted to pursue their study somewhere else need to go to different forum. Different country has different educational system. So be practical when you ask any question in this valuable forum.

Should I change PhD?
G

Department of analytical science, you know anything about that department please?

Should I change PhD?
G

Which department?

No Funding Available & Position Already Filled
G

I sympathise totally. There are lots of these unprofessional types around unfortunately who obviously don't care how many people's time they waste.

Unless of course, they are saying that as a polite excuse not to consider your application. This is equally unhelpful because it doesn't help you to see how to change your approach for next time.

Should I change PhD?
G

If you haven't done so already, I would suggest that you discuss your problems with your supervisor. If you like your topic it would be a shame to have all the upheaval of uprooting to go elsewhere, especially if, as you say it could be like where you are now.

Should I change PhD?
G

Well, I started a PhD 8 months ago, the topic was great and all, but now, the people get on my nerves and the supervisor can't stop going from one thread to another one, I am losing direction, really!! In the meantime, I looked for other PhDs and found one in the UK, in UMIST. I heard it is a good institute. The UMIST called me for an interview. If they accept me, should I go? Or not? There is the risk that it will be like here as well...I really don't know what to do...Any suggestions?

No Funding Available & Position Already Filled
G

they probably dont like you

try again

No Funding Available & Position Already Filled
G

You know what relly annoys me, when you see an advertised position, you write off, and then the supervisor turns round and says sorry theres no funding. The other thing that really gets on my nerves is you write to a supervisor and they go oh sorry the positions already filled. Despite that the project will stay on there for the next few months, I mean seriously, whats the point?

PhDs in Germany
G

It really does seem that in general in Germany, the expectations of you in a research institute are high but they're not investing so much in you as budding researcher. In the UK though, it is more a 2-way thing.

Of course there is always the risk of being lumbered with a bad supervisor wherever you go. In Germany, the pay is the same for everyone regardless of nationality, with the few exceptions that some are lucky enough to be on the full BAT pay. Having compared notes with various other researchers also from other institutes, many did complain of similar things to what I did - I know I'm not the only one to be saying these things, in fact I have heard some real horror stories!

In my case, the professor had made a big song and dance about my PhD position, having advertised it in the New Scientist etc. and invited numerous people from all over the place to apply. Yet 6 months into my being there, he quite casually tells me that he hadn't written a research proposal for my project, and that he didn't know if there was enough money for me to be able to continue my work there.

The other difference to do with the money is that whereas in the UK, you're not permitted to begin a PhD programme before funding has been secured, which is normally for 3 years. Whereas, in Germany they don't secure funding beforehand. You sometimes end up on yearly, 6 month or even 3 month contracts, and you can never be sure if they will be extended.

PhDs in Germany
G

Karen, to me it sounds like your problems have nothing to do with that you were in Germany, but rather that you were with a bad supervisor.
And getting funding for international students isn't all that straight-forward in UK either.

PhDs in Germany
G

As I said before, the having to do other people's work is the reason why people can't complete within the usual 3 or so years and why many don't finish at all. And, yes, it was exactly my point that PhD's require original publication-worthy work; another fact that seemed to go astray at the institute I worked at! I was actually speaking from my own personal experience of having to be a data production line for 12 months by the way!

How good are Universities?
G

The reputation of a research group can be assesed by looking at what they have published in relationship to the size of a group and in what journals. Look out for science, nature, cell. Nature for example rejects 95% of al papers and only takes the very best.