Signup date: Unknown
Last login: Never
Post count: 8969
first of all, decide now- hanging on for another year won't help. If you apply for another position you can say that you tried it for 1 year.
Yes, supervisors can be very unfair and have the advantage on their side. On a more positive note, you'll probably find some other PhD position if you look. I know someone who did it (in germany) and her only regret was that she took the first position she could get because she thought she wouldn't find anything.
The point of a PhD is to do some original work. How much of the original ideas come from you depends on you. If you don't come up with any idea your supervisor in any country will tell you what to do if you are wasting time.
And remember, in the end its the supervisors grant your living off, so she/he has some say. Plus, you should benefit from their input because they generally have more experience and can tell you what is worth persuing and what not. If your idea is good no supervisor will say no.
Ok, to make things clearer: a wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter gets paid BAT 1/2. This is just the salary they are paying you to live of during your PhD. It has nothing to do with having to work half-time for someone else- otherwise you couldn't do your PhD in 3 years. You work full time on your project for half of the usual university salary. And in the end you have more or less the same income as in the UK.
yes anon, the different research ethos is an issue. In germany if you did the work, you were on the paper as author. Here, you're not - because of politics. There are too many names on the cell paper, so my supervisor put me on another paper I didn't do a single experiment for. I prefer german ethos.
In my PhD lab here we have Spanish, French, Irish, German, Chinese, two english, Irish and a KiWi working in the UK. We all speak English as a general language and working with them is great fun. We always understand each other, even if it gets difficult inbetween.
When you choose a lab for your PhD look at their publications to see if they are good. Either they have their fair amount of recent cell, nature and science papers - or they don't. Crap labs can be found in the uk as well as in germany. When you apply for a postdoc people won;t say: Oh wow, you've done your PhD in the UK!, They'll say Oh , that cell paper you got out of your PhD was really interesting! Or: You were in the lab of X. Impressive, that's a really top quality lab.
Anon, it sounds like you are having the same problem as me. We have a flexible working agreement in our lab, and most of the people start around 10am while I start at 7am. When I leave an hour or so before them I get dirty looks but they don't understand that I have actually been there 3 hours before they even came in! I too have lots of research experience, but feel like I am not getting the credit I deserve.
What he should be doing is letting you exercise your initiative! - If not straight away in the way of designing experiments, you should be able to discuss your thoughts and ideas with him without fear of criticism or put-downs. I've had 2 research supervisors; one who I got along with very well, and one who was a complete idiot. The latter one was well-meaning, but it was the general opinion of everyone that he wasn't actually suited to being a research supervisor! His behaviour in fact, was a bit like what you described about your supervisor.
It really is down to luck whether you have a good, bad, or mediocre supervisor. Since you have been in your department for long enough, would you be able at all to choose someone else?
Yes its perfect true. When ever i feel that i am bit low or in agony i come to this site. As i read through the messages i find that i am just one among several other Ph.d students who shares similar exps to me. So one of my moral booster is FIND A Ph.D .COM and then listening to music and enjoying reading other than subject. As its not that everyday are same during Ph.d days. Cheers
Should I expect interaction with my supervisor to be a 2way thing then as the others have suggested he has a problem with that and would prefer it if i just did as i was told. What is the sort of situation i should be expecting? What are your experiences?
Thanks
In my case for example they kept me waiting for 3 months, when I called the University the secretary didn't know much about it coz is the supervisor that has to choose the students going on the short list. I just think that your prospective supervisor is very busy at the moment or cannot decide!Maybe try to e-mail him again.
If you don't make it on the short list they should send you a letter and an e-mail. Silence means that probably the supervisor has not considered the matter yet particularly at this time of the year with examinations in course etc.. Good luck I hope you will get a response soon! keep trying!
I get the impression sometimes that students who are, say self-funded, they are treated differently to students who are funded by industry, especially if the latter student comes from outside of the EU. I fully realise that this might not always be the case, but where it's more the university's interest that the student is successful in their studies, they might sometimes be treated slightly better than others.
Therefore I'm a bit surprised that in your case, you are funded by industry. I really don't see how it would be in your supervisor's interest to create more obstacles to put in your way, and his behaviour sounds completely unacceptable. Personally, I would set about finding another supervisor.
Not that it would ever be in anyone's interest to make someones life miserable! I just thought that if, maybe you were self-funded unlike everyone else, this might explain why he is treating you badly. Good luck, I hope it works out good for you in the end!
PostgraduateForum Is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, 77 Sidney St, Sheffield, S1 4RG, UK. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766
An active and supportive community.
Support and advice from your peers.
Your postgraduate questions answered.
Use your experience to help others.
Enter your email address below to get started with your forum account
Enter your username below to login to your account
An email has been sent to your email account along with instructions on how to reset your password. If you do not recieve your email, or have any futher problems accessing your account, then please contact our customer support.
or continue as guest
To ensure all features on our website work properly, your computer, tablet or mobile needs to accept cookies. Our cookies don’t store your personal information, but provide us with anonymous information about use of the website and help us recognise you so we can offer you services more relevant to you. For more information please read our privacy policy
Agree Agree