Overview of bewildered

Overview

Avatar placeholder
bewildered
Sunday, 8 June 2008 at 6:52pm
Thursday, 12 September 2019 at 3:37pm
1402
Login to send a private message to bewildered
page 1 of 62 recent posts

Thread: Certain odd jobs vs potential 'real' position

posted
12-Sep-19, 15:39
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 week ago
Check the contract - there will probably be a notice period. But personally in your shoes I would absolutely apply for f/t jobs, take anything offered and quit.

Thread: Efficient Ways to Encourage/Comfort, Please help

posted
10-Sep-19, 21:00
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 week ago
How realistic is it that she will get an academic job do you think? Is she getting interviews? I think your reaction is probably different if on paper she's competitive as a candidate and just missing out, compared to someone chasing an increasingly unlikely dream. If it's the former, do you have a sense of what's going wrong and whether say interview coaching might be a worthwhile investment. If it's the latter, I think you need to start stressing that there are good non-academic alternatives, that it's ok to walk away from academia etc. Maybe you could have an 'in an ideal world' what would we want to have in our lives, where would we want to live etc conversation and gradually bring her round to the idea that there are other futures that could be great but don't involve an academic job. Good luck - the uncertainties of such a long job search must be tough on both of you.

Thread: Got revise and resubmit for PhD at VIVA - what to do about job?

posted
19-Aug-19, 14:44
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
Before you do anything re the job, ask your supervisor if there's any way to suspend studies I..e stop the R&R clock on health grounds. It might be possible.

Thread: Advise:Looking for a job and they request the name of my supervisor?

posted
11-Aug-19, 17:55
edited about 14 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
Safest way to make sure you can't sue, while still providing a factually accurate reference.

Thread: I want to quit, but will regre the work I've put in

posted
11-Aug-19, 14:53
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
Everything you write suggests that you should take the job. Research and academia are not for everyone and there's no disgrace in accepting that and walking away to something you think offers more of what you want out of life. I suspect that once you're out of the environment, your regrets will subside as you'll be busy with something else. At another stage in life you may feel differently and want another go but for now I'd quit if I were you.

Thread: Advise:Looking for a job and they request the name of my supervisor?

posted
11-Aug-19, 14:43
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
It's not illegal to give a bad reference - that's a myth. References have to be factually accurate. I would imagine someone will be willing to confirm dates of study and the award of a PhD but given the complaints, I suspect HR advice would be not to go beyond that.

Thread: Decieved by my PhD supervisor.

posted
06-Aug-19, 15:22
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
I can understand why you feel upset, but this might not be intentional deception but rather an unfortunate series of events that has engulfed your department. Licences are unpredictable and sometimes regulations change or you get a picky assessor, and with the best will in the world things can go wrong. Also your supervisor might have known generally that the university / faculty was in financial trouble but not the extent to which your department was going to be cut. University leaders keep such matters very close to their chests.
It sounds like he's had to scale back ambition for the group to adapt to the new reality and that includes moulding your project into something that's doable in the circumstances. You have to decide whether it's worth continuing with or whether you want to cut your losses and apply elsewhere.
On the money, if your supervisor is HoD and has to cut 21 million from the department, those are massive cuts. He's probably looking at major redundancies which will gut research groups. He can't in those circumstances be seen to favour his own group for funding particularly if objectively as he's told you, he thinks your project can be done without the funding, when others perhaps cannot. It's absolutely reasonable of you to decide this isn't what was offered and walk away, but I think you are being a bit unfair in your assessment of someone who's probably living through a nightmare right now.

Thread: Lost all interest after my viva!!

posted
06-Aug-19, 15:07
edited about 21 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
I think most people have felt like this at this stage of the PhD, and I've no real advice other than one final push and you are done. I think in the long run you would feel gutted to have quit so close to the finish. You're doing the right things in breaking it down and doing short concentrated bursts of work. The only other thing I can suggest is rewarding yourself. Could you incentivise this with something concrete, like booking a holiday for the week after you are due to resubmit? Or a day doing something you love, when you've got to a particular point?

Thread: Is it a disaster?

posted
01-Aug-19, 13:54
edited about 59 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
Universities have external targets for PhD students submitting on time (usually 4 years but some subjects may differ) and the penalties for missing it can mean losing research council funding for future PhD students. If your department is near the threshold, and your supervisor has a record of students not completing, she probably is feeling under a lot of pressure herself about you finishing on time (especially if you've been funded). I am telling you this as she may be aware that in those circumstances extensions might be hard to get approved by the faculty so is pushing you hard as a result. You need to talk to her, show her a realistic plan of what still needs doing and how long it will take, and jointly strategise how best to move forward regarding an extension request or any loopholes to temporarily stop the deadline clock for you. She may be assuming you have more written that you do so now is the time to be brutally honest.

Thread: How Long Did you Wait for your Viva?

posted
23-Jul-19, 15:30
edited about 5 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
Definitely follow up. Were your examiners already chosen? If not that could cause a delay but otherwise they usually try to arrange a viva within 3 months of submission.

Thread: Paper submission - awaiting final decision after awaiting admin processing

posted
23-Jul-19, 15:27
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
Two possibilities - it could be a desk reject and the editor is writing up why or it could just be that the status visible is a holding status while reviewers are sought. You can't do anything so try not to worry.

Thread: Got a PhD in Teesside

posted
25-Jun-19, 23:53
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
In terms of the university, while in general not so highly ranked, it's meant to be good at eg animation and computer game design. Place - well it's poor and that does influence things like shopping, leisure etc. Good modern art gallery though. You could also commute from nicer nearby towns - if the seaside is your thing, Saltburn by the Sea is cute and has a direct train link.

But I've never lived there just been to a couple of exhibitions at MIMA.

Thread: Doing part of my PhD remotely in Europe while working full time?

posted
23-Jun-19, 18:52
edited about 18 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
I think timefortea's point about it probably needing to be p/t is very true. It is also going to be more like the equivalent of 4 years however you do it than 3 realistically. However supportive your work is, stuff happens that pulls you in different directions and it's always the PhD that is lowest priority for them. Distance learning is viable but you do miss out. I think another thing that you might want to consider is career outlook. This way would be great to help you perhaps advance in your current career, but might be sub-optimal if you wanted to move into academia.

Thread: After the complaint, what should I do if the university doesn’t take an action?

posted
23-Jun-19, 18:44
edited about 18 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
I think there is an element of truth in what rewt says however unwelcome it may be to hear. Students filing complaints tend to want to be 100% in the right and for the person complained about to suffer. The problem is that there is usually right and wrong on both sides, which tends to leave all concerned feeling dissatisfied. In particular, as another thread is showing, students are frequently shocked to discover their own behaviour has been documented and will be taken into account. Or the rules ensuring equal treatment of all students will be taken seriously. In short, I wouldn't get over-invested in the complaints process, you've made the complaint, but you need to move on and start on the next phase of your career too. Don't obsess about it as you are very unlikely to be wholly satisfied by the outcome.

Thread: Can university use personal mental health against me

posted
23-Jun-19, 18:31
edited about 23 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
Well if you asked them to behave in an inappropriate and unprofessional manner regarding supervision, and they refused and your complaint is about quality of supervision then I'm afraid it's relevant.
page 1 of 62 recent posts

Postgraduate
Forum

Copyright ©2018
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

PostgraduateForum is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, 77 Sidney St, Sheffield, S1 4RG, UK. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766