Overview of bewildered

Overview

Avatar placeholder
bewildered
Sunday, 8 June 2008 at 6:52pm
Sunday, 28 June 2020 at 5:58pm
1429
Login to send a private message to bewildered
page 1 of 64 recent posts

Thread: Lectureship v postdoc - advice please

posted
28-Jun-20, 17:58
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 5 days ago
Yes the obvious move having gained a permanent lectureship is to apply for an individual fellowship for new investigators rather than going backwards to being a junior researcher on a research project as pd1598 points out. Precarity in academia is such that everyone understands switching between temporary teaching and research jobs as you need to pay the bills, but giving up a permanent role without a very obvious reason (e.g. family caring responsibilities mean you need to move area or your department is being closed down) will raise eyebrows.

Thread: Lectureship v postdoc - advice please

posted
28-Jun-20, 13:57
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 5 days ago
If the lectureship was a permanent post it would look odd. Not so if it were a one year temporary teaching post. However, in the latter case, what is sometimes difficult is keeping up your research agenda, while doing a lot of teaching, so that you remain competitive for research posts.
If you are choosing for next academic year between a temporary teaching post and a research post though, I'd stay on the research side. Teaching next academic year will be brutal for everyone and if you've not already got lectures written and existing teaching experience so you know how things work, it will be so hard. Teaching mainly online for more hours than usual (including at a growing number of places evening and weekend teaching looks likely), disgruntled and struggling students, working from home where possible so less mentoring possible and the physical risks of any face-to-face teaching. Everyone's dreading it. For a permanent post, it's probably worth it but less so otherwise...Although given all the redundancies being announced, permanent may not actually be permanent, but to be fair that's the case with most jobs at the moment.

Thread: How to find a post-doc in UK or Canada

posted
09-Jun-20, 15:41
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 weeks ago
I'm afraid that there aren't many social sciences postdocs out there compared to the sciences (especially at the moment with hiring freezes). There are various centralised schemes; in the UK, British Academy, ESRC, Leverhulme, Canada, I think it's SSRC; where you need the backing of a university and submit your own project proposal. Otherwise, for the ones where you work on someone's grant, you are probably seeing all that's out there.I assume you're on the mailing list for the appropriate disciplinary association already, that's the other place I see postdocs advertised?

Thread: Quit PhD to go back for a Masters, then retry Phd?

posted
06-Jun-20, 17:36
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 weeks ago
I'd cut your losses and leave. You sound unhappy and given the political situation in HK is likely to get worse not better,you may be better off elsewhere. Do you think you might want to work in Germany / EU in the future? If so will not having a masters be an issue? I know from working there myself that they expected your education to map onto the Bologna system in job applications, but luckily I'm a social scientist so we've had to do a Masters before the PhD for decades anyway. It might though be worth doing a masters anyway to have a clearer idea what area of physics you want to work in, as it sounds like you're still unsure.

Thread: Part-time PhD while working full-time

posted
29-May-20, 20:59
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
Hi OP,

I have a friend who managed it while teaching. It was an EdD though rather than a standard PhD. The course was set up for people working in education so was easier to manage. She had a supportive headteacher though and I think went p/t at work for the final year. She did it out of interest and never wanted an academic career but it's certainly served her well in the education world. She's now doing education policy work and is on double what she was earning as a teacher. It might not be the right route for you but in case you'd not come across professional doctorates, I thought it was worth mentioning.

Thread: How hard is it to find a postdoc?

posted
26-May-20, 13:22
edited about 22 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
It might be just a realistic assessment of what she thinks the academic job market in your field is going to look like for the next few years rather than anything personal. If what's already happening in the US and Australia is anything to go by, and it's certainly looking bad here in the UK too, it's going to be very hard indeed for people to get a foot on the academic ladder. It might not be the worse idea to see what info your careers people have on industry jobs so that you're well-informed on all possibilities.

Thread: Postdoc applications

posted
26-May-20, 13:12
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
Anecdotally I've been hearing at my university, that application levels for the small number of postdocs that can be advertised during a hiring freeze are very high and that the HR side is very slow as their systems don't work too well away from the university network. I'd give it a month to 6 weeks before writing things off at the moment.

Thread: Offered a phd but only 3k bursary - stressed!

posted
19-May-20, 16:55
edited about 7 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
You might find this helpful: https://fundsonline.org.uk/ But the problem is that the sums of money are often small and one-off. I really doubt (particularly given the recession to come) that you could pull enough together and it would be a near constant task.
Is the choice of Huddersfield to work with a particular expert? Huddersfield isn't covered by AHRC PhD funding as far as I can tell, but Leeds, York and Sheffield are in the White Rose partnership. Their next deadline would be January 2021 but that would give you time to identify suitable supervisors and work on a proposal. It might be an option if you have a strong academic background or if the research might interest a collaborative sponsor.

Thread: Foreign language requirements for Modern Languages graduate

posted
20-Apr-20, 13:53
edited about 6 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
German universities tend not to be flexible in my experience but if you did a year abroad at a university, studying in German, you may have done the exam already? I know I had to pass one to enrol.

Thread: Advice on 'cold emailing' PIs for post-doc

posted
14-Apr-20, 18:15
edited about 2 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
What I meant by holding off, is that personally I wouldn't waste good contacts by speculatively emailing at a point, when the PIs don't know what's going to happen, when in a month things might be a bit clearer regarding funding (will new projects be delayed, or extensions given), the REF, when universities might be able to reopen etc. Applying for an actual job is rather different and of course you should do that.

Thread: Is there any other experimental science PhD student who's feeling as lost and anxious as me now

posted
14-Apr-20, 18:08
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
+1 with Nead - delete that email if it's anything like your post. It will only make you sound like you're not prepared to do the work for your thesis that you've been asked to do. Let's face it, if we're lucky enough just to be bored and frustrated right now, then we're the fortunate ones who aren't dealing with illness and bereavement.

Thread: Influence of covid19 over funding

posted
14-Apr-20, 18:03
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
I think you probably would need to work out whether it would be viable to support yourself for 1.5-2 years in this place (and if you need a visa whether that would be a problem). It might be worth asking about provision to study part-time etc and if there are any fees that might apply to you after the funding runs out. If he's making it clear that he's retiring on a certain date, does that mean he's running his lab down? Would you be supervised if you weren't finished? Sorry for all the pessimistic questions but a friend got very badly abandoned in a similar position, so it might be worth asking upfront.

On the impact of the pandemic, it seems that some university systems will be hit worse than others. It sounds like the USA is preparing for major cuts even at Ivy League universities, but somehow I'd imagine the Sweden / Norway type countries will have fewer cutbacks.

Thread: Advice on 'cold emailing' PIs for post-doc

posted
10-Apr-20, 13:02
edited about 8 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
Many universities have announced / will announce next week hiring freezes unless 'business critical' as the pandemic is leaving many institutions in real financial danger from what I'm hearing from my own institution and friends elsewhere. Unfortunately postdocs are unlikely to ever be seen as business critical. If you can, it might be better to hold off for a bit, and see if the government is going to bail out universities (see BBC and Guardian reports on this today) and then things may loosen up a bit. I'd also be looking at industry options very seriously.

Thread: Concerned I made the right choice of university...

posted
17-Feb-20, 19:48
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 5 months ago
I think there's several reasons, some with more merit than others.
1) There are so few jobs in the humanities that you have to be extremely good to stand a chance. It's very different to the sciences where it's relatively easy to get a postdoc. This means there will be lots of very appointable people applying for each job, and any imperfection rules you out. If you've not been socialised to understand the market as you've not got supervisors who are particularly well-networked themselves, you're at an immediate disadvantage. Most PhDs from ex-polys have that disadvantage unless they've been savvy enough to spot knowledge gaps and get advice.
2) There are fewer PhD students in the ex-poly departments (again talking humanities here), so they tend to get swamped with teaching that they're told is a career necessity, and offered less exposure to cutting edge research through visiting speakers etc. They are also often disadvantaged in access to methods training courses. There is quite simply less money floating around to pay for those things. This means their skill set may be less well-aligned with what research-focused universities are looking for.
3) Some not all humanities subjects are very stratified. There is a firm belief that the best go to Oxford/Cambridge/UCL and therefore that's where you should recruit from. It's not quite as bad as in the US where pedigree as they call it there, and recommendations from top names are more important than what's on the cv, but it's getting there.
There are plenty of good humanities academics working in ex-polys, and like I say I think some subjects are more open-minded that others. But the OP is going to have to work that little bit harder to stand out, which is why I think her concern that her project isn't strong, is actually the stronger reason to consider moving.

Thread: Concerned I made the right choice of university...

posted
17-Feb-20, 17:01
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 5 months ago
I think this might depend on what subject. I'm a social scientist but from talking to colleagues, I have been given the impression that this matters a lot in philosophy but not at all in media studies. I'd be more worried though about your description of your project as not strong - if there's not much chance of good publications because the methods or theory are flawed then I think that would scupper you.
If you stay put, make sure you understand how your subject works - which associations should you join, what conferences are best to go to, what does a strong job candidate in your field look like. If you are in a not very research active department, the staff may not know this themselves, so you might have to be proactive in seeking 'professionalisation' training. In my subject, the main associations have postgrad networks that offer lots of this - you might find the same.
page 1 of 64 recent posts

Postgraduate
Forum

Copyright ©2018
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

PostgraduateForum is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, 77 Sidney St, Sheffield, S1 4RG, UK. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766