Overview of bewildered

Overview

Avatar placeholder
bewildered 4 star member
Sunday, 8 June 2008 at 6:52pm
Monday, 9 October 2017 at 7:21pm
1306
Login to send a private message to bewildered
page 1 of 56 recent posts

Thread: Postdoc jobs in Europe

posted
09-Oct-17, 19:21
edited about 29 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 week ago
Netherlands is https://www.academictransfer.com/

Thread: Postdoc jobs in Europe

posted
07-Oct-17, 20:45
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 week ago
https://euraxess.ec.europa.eu/ might be of some use. Also is there a European Association for your subject area - mine at least has some postdoc listings on its website. But I don't think there's really a pan-European catch-all site. Perhaps if you posted the countries you're interested in, then people might know the jobs.ac.uk equivalents for those countries?

Thread: Requested change in supervision - a bit scared...

posted
03-Oct-17, 21:36
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 weeks ago
It will depend on your own behaviour. If you try to manipulate your fellow students and most importantly your new supervisor into having negative views of an otherwise well-liked individual, then the consensus will be that you are the problem. If you behave professionally and don't throw around dubious mental health diagnoses like in this post then it will be fine. Your fellow students will probably gossip but I doubt most of the staff will know or care. And if the supervisory relationship had broken down, your former supervisor is quite probably cracking open the champagne, rather than plotting against you, as there is nothing worse than the hours and days trying to get somebody over the finishing line, who you know loathes you. Honestly PhD students are always convinced that they are the centre of staff discussion and lives - they really aren't. Colleagues elsewhere provide far more entertaining gossip on the whole.

And sorry if this sounds harsh but as there are many people posting on this forum seeking support with major mental health problems, please cut out the dodgy mental health diagnoses about your supervisor. It's not necessary or appropriate and may put vulnerable people off seeking advice.

Thread: Reality check

posted
29-Sep-17, 16:39
edited about 25 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 weeks ago
Meep I suspect you have landed up in a department that is unused to PhD students. This might mean supervisors who have little supervisory experience, no dedicated administrators and few PhD colleagues / training opportunities. While this can be a chance to be a big fish in a small pond, and some have thrived in that environment, it sounded like you'd really benefit from a larger PhD community, organised graduate school, experienced supervisors etc as that would give you the atmosphere you were hoping for. Are there any other universities that would be geographically viable? Does your current university have any doctoral training partnerships with other institutions? Sometimes cross-institution supervision can be managed in those circumstances.
If the answer to those questions is no, I'd suggest making an appointment to see whoever formally has responsibility for PhD students in your faculty (a dean or similar) or failing that your HoD. Explain what has happened - go in with a long list of issues. Ask about changing registration from distance to p/t and ask if they'd give you a workspace if that happened (being seen regularly in a dept even a disorganised one) can help.
But if I'm honest, if it's possible I'd leave and restart somewhere else.

Thread: Not-to-be-mentioned-option post-PhD

posted
13-Sep-17, 20:18
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 1 month ago
I am in a field where getting any lectureship is a big achievement these days. Some junior staff at ex-92s are truly excellent. My eyebrows would be raised at the OP's statement but largely because most people apply for any job in our sub-field regardless of the institution and it would seem a bit clueless to assume getting a job at a post-92 was a walk in the park.
I would be wary about lumping all the former polys in one group by the way, some expect research much more than others. They have diverged quite a bit as a group.

Thread: Applying for PostDoc Research - choosing an institution close by?

posted
30-Aug-17, 22:44
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
No it's not heavily based on teaching. The host institution though will need to be able to provide career development for you e.g. courses or other training, involvement in the activities of a research group and if they are investing in you, the BA will want you to be an active member of the department, rather than someone who will put in occasional appearances. You need to think of it really as a full-time job with occasional work at home possibilities - it is a bit different in terms of expectations to the PhD if you've been used to doing as you please more or less. Have you talked to your supervisor about what institutions might be a good fit?

Thread: Changing University after Starting a PhD?

posted
29-Aug-17, 22:32
edited about 12 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
It sounds from what you say as if doing the masters either as a stand-alone or as a 1+3 programme might be helpful in building up your experience of research design and thus confidence. If it's funded, don't worry too much about the extra time. Candidates without that can really struggle with defining their PhD project, finding a viable gap in the literature etc and so end up spending longer than they hoped with the upgrade process. It might therefore be a time-saver in the end.

Thread: Applying for PostDoc Research - choosing an institution close by?

posted
29-Aug-17, 22:26
edited about 27 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
The BA postdocs are about the institution providing you with training and experience to make it more likely you could get a lectureship at the end. They look for fit on this between you and the host department / mentor and so I don't think the kind of p/t association you suggest would fly, as it would limit the case for support to an non-viable extent. The host institution also has to agree to sponsor your application as it has costs for them, so they will want something from you in return (so again p/t residency isn't likely to make them keen). Have you made contact with any depts yet? Some are only allowed to put one candidate per year to an internal competition and then only the best overall candidates can apply so you really need an academic on board, who is going to push for you. There's only 45 nationally per year so rationing applications internally is a strategy that's increasingly used.

Thread: Masters without honours

posted
29-Aug-17, 22:15
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
It depends why you haven't a honours degree. If you studied in Scotland and didn't bother to do the honours year, there are probably routes in (scottish universities are likely to be more understanding & to have pathways). If you have a pass degree because you failed final year, then it will be difficult if not impossible to do what you want. Even the Open university only lets you transfer so many credits.

Thread: University teacher only, without research

posted
16-Aug-17, 16:14
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
Quote From TreeofLife:
Quote From bewildered:
In both the UK and USA student numbers are in fact falling at the moment


I think applications are falling, but attendees are staying the same because unis reduce the grades and requirements to get on the course. At least, that's what my department is doing to maintain student numbers...


Not according to the stats for either country I'm afraid. Think about it - you accept applications are falling and you say that your department drops entry standards to keep its numbers steady, so it's taking people who would have gone to a lower ranked university. And so on down the rankings - that's why numbers have collapsed at the lower end of the market e.g. London Met has shrunk from 28,000 students to a target of 10,000 for 2017). You can only drop entry standards so far without ending with un-viably high dropout rates and the bottom ranked institutions were already there. Some institutions in the UK are now in danger of failing (and govt policy on Brexit and immigration are increasing that risk) - and in the US small and poor colleges are just shutting down.

The TEF doesn't actually measure teaching - and is a bad joke (not bitter either as I work for a gold institution that absolutely shouldn't be). The teaching only posts in the RG are about cutting costs by increasing the amount of teaching each postholder does and reducing those academics' bargaining power. You can only really move institutions through research outputs so teaching only staff are basically trapped. That leaves very little leverage on promotion/ pay/ conditions for teaching only staff, and certainly where I work you need a nationally recognised teaching profile to get promoted by that route - which in turn requires grant income and publications but on teaching i.e. not it seems what the OP really wants to do.

Thread: University teacher only, without research

posted
15-Aug-17, 16:03
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
In both the UK and USA student numbers are in fact falling at the moment, so unfortunately a lot of the wholly teaching focused jobs are rather insecure, and unions in both countries are fighting to try to stop casualisation. You have to really be very careful about considering whether it's viable as a long-term career. I know a couple of people who have had to move city most years for some time now chasing one year teaching fellowships - it's not a life I'd fancy myself.
How resistant are you to research? In both countries there are teaching focused institutions, where the majority of a role for a permanent contract would be teaching and admin but there would be some expectations of research (but much less than the more prestigious universities). If you for example don't want to do lab research, could you consider researching teaching biology and publishing on that? Or perhaps something very applied rather than blue skies research? One other possibility are jobs that involve you running degree programmes or another large administrative role alongside teaching - they tend though not to be entry level jobs but worth checking adverts to see what sort of experience they look for.
If teaching itself is what really excites you, you could also try qualifying to teach in secondary schools or colleges?

Thread: Academic Job Mobility in the European Context

posted
10-Aug-17, 16:00
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 2 months ago
Even with schemes to aid mobility like Marie Curie postdocs etc, the European academic job market is very variable in how willing each country is to hire PhDs from elsewhere. And so what your chances are post-PhD also vary (there will also be things like % of graduates doing a PhD and whether international PhD graduates have the same chances as home students that make a difference to your chances).
I think though there are considerable differences between those countries. Some i.e. Denmark / Switzerland seem to have far more international staff - I think this is because a lot is taught in English in Denmark and the main Swiss languages are widely spoken by other Europeans so the markets are more open, and so there seems to be less of a guarantee of an academic job post PhD. In contrast I have yet to meet a Norwegian PhD who wanted to stay in academia and wasn't found something - however unexciting - but maybe my sample could be very skewed. But I see jobs advertised internationally in Denmark / Switzerland and don't for Norway. Sweden / Finland are I think somewhere inbetween. You might want to have a look at the European University Institute's Academic Career Observatory site - there's some interesting info there on all of this.

Thread: Funding for Masters when you already have a PhD

posted
29-Jul-17, 20:49
edited about 26 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
Could you ask the admissions team to put you in touch with one of the university's student finance advisors to get an informed opinion? They tend to be rather better informed than the people in the student loans call centres. You say you can't find work but I'm guessing you mean in your field - if the loan is not possible, might you be able to earn enough in a not so great job to let you do the course part-time. Universities are often quite accommodating in agreeing instalment plans for paying p/g fees.
I'm guessing you might already know about this but many people don't realise that 6 month post-graduation employment data is also available for Masters courses and PhDs. If you haven't already looked, definitely ask about it to see whether the course you want to do delivers in terms of employment outcomes you want (DLHE data is what to ask for).

Thread: Is R&R experience a bomb for potential employer in academia?

posted
27-Jul-17, 17:39
edited about 27 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
I don't see a) why anyone needs to know or b) why you feel ashamed about it. I've never seen an application form that asks about this, and on your cv you only need to say the date each degree was actually awarded. PhDs from the UK are not graded so unless you tell them, why would anyone know? And there are many reasons why a PhD could take longer, so I doubt anyone would assume anything. And tbh getting 12 or 6 months corrections is far more normal an outcome than the impression you get from this forum. It really isn't the catastrophe scenario you imagine. You have the degree that's what matters. What you will be judged on in the academic job market is primarily your publications honestly.
I also don't think it's the norm to be just given a job in your PhD department as you seem to think it is - people will try to help out new PhDs with part-time / temporary work, if something is available, but often there's nothing to offer. It's not personal. I think you're perhaps reading negative signals into things that aren't really there, which is understandable as being unemployed is not fun, but please don't fret about the R&R. It really won't matter - get that paper out to a journal and start feeling proud of what you've achieved.

Thread: Books about publishing

posted
26-Jul-17, 21:07
edited about 20 seconds later
Avatar for bewildered
posted about 3 months ago
No book suggestions but the main disciplinary association in your field might well have links to advice tailored to your subject.
page 1 of 56 recent posts

Postgraduate
Forum

Copyright ©2017
All rights reserved

Postgraduate Forum

Masters Degrees

PhD Opportunities

PostgraduateForum is a trading name of FindAUniversity Ltd
FindAUniversity Ltd, Sellers Wheel, 151 Arundel Street, Sheffield, S1 2NU, United Kingdom. Tel +44 (0) 114 268 4940 Fax: +44 (0) 114 268 5766